Nolita Pizza

J

Jatinder Singh

über Google

Thin crust perfection with a smile! It’s a fantastic spot for thin crust pizza lovers. The pizzas are light, crispy, and full of flavour, easily among the best in Little Italy. What makes the experience even better is the friendly and welcoming customer service. Staff are warm, quick, and genuinely caring. A must-visit for great pizza and good vibes.

A

Allan Classified

über Google

I was actually going through little italy for another restaurant but the smell brought me in. A quaint little unassuming place with the atmosphere of a pizzeria in italy is often some of the best pizza you can find and I had to check it out. The margarita had just come out as it turns out and I made quick work of it at a small table outside. It's got that thin foldable crust you want with the perfect little roll of grease from quality fresh mozzarella. It doesn't get much better than this for the cost believe me. I got to dinner with my friends and just pretended I was famished but really the meal I got wasn't even as good as that slice from here but nobody has to know about that but me and Nolita ha!

J

Jae Jun

über Google

1st day in NYC, couldn’t eat Prince Street pizza since it was cash only - I quickly looked up Nolita’s and it didn’t disappoint. Exactly what I imagined when I thought of a NY slice. Thin, crunchy, and simply delicious. $5 for a large slice that they heat up after you order and comes out quickly. Would definitely come back next time.

D

Debisree Ray

über Google

I stopped by this little slice of heaven on a weeknight after an event, around 8:30 or 9 p.m. The place wasn’t too crowded, which was perfect. I ordered at the counter, and the staff was incredibly friendly — she told me to grab a seat, and she’d bring the pizza over once it was ready. The menu had several tempting options, but I went with two slices: a deep-dish square spicy pepperoni and a burrata with basil slice. The burrata came out first, and it was absolutely divine — the thin, crispy crust topped generously with fresh burrata, olive oil, and basil. The ingredients tasted so fresh that it truly elevated the whole experience. I’d highly recommend this one — you don’t often find burrata pizza done this well. Next came the deep-dish spicy pepperoni, which was massive and indulgent. The slice was thick, heavy, and loaded with spicy, flavorful pepperoni — they definitely didn’t skimp on toppings. One slice alone would’ve been enough, but it was so good I couldn’t resist finishing both. By the end, I was stuffed but completely satisfied. The best part? The whole meal cost just $11 including tax, which felt like a steal for the quality. It’s a cozy, affordable, and genuinely delicious spot — highly recommend it, and I’ll definitely be back!

M

Michael Aponte

über Google

Tried Nolita Pizza and honestly, it was just alright. The pizza itself wasn’t bad, but the sauce wasn’t really saucing – could’ve used a little more flavor. I also felt like they could’ve left the pie in the oven just a bit longer to really crisp it up. The atmosphere was a little dry no music, so you mostly just hear everyone’s conversations. A little background music could go a long way in making the vibe better. Customer service was okay, but could definitely be warmer. All in all, it’s not a bad spot, just has room for improvement.