Andolini's Pizzeria Cherry Street

Hideaway Pizza is a Tulsa pizza restaurant offering Italian-inspired pies and classic dishes. Customers praise fast, friendly service and flavorful pizzas such as Porkpalooza, Pizza of the Gods, Maui Magic, and Big Country, plus salads like a customizable Cobb Salad with grilled chicken. Takeout is reliably ready on time, and the venue carries a warm, boho-chic vibe.

East Village Bohemian Pizzeria offers a welcoming, colorful dining experience in Tulsa at 818 E 3rd St. Guests praise attentive service, a cozy atmosphere, and a menu of crispy, juicy pizzas, salads, and pastas. Reviews note high-quality Italian ingredients, house-made pastas, and thoughtful touches like outdoor heaters and blankets. It's a standout, non-chain spot celebrated for great food and friendly staff.

Pie Hole Pizzeria sits at 2708 E 15th St, Tulsa, offering customizable slices with a woodfire-esque crust. Reviews praise bold flavors, roasted garlic, and friendly, quick service, plus vegan options like cauliflower crust with vegan cheese. The cozy lobby features a pinball table and local flyers, and there is no indoor seating. Slices are affordable and highly customizable.

Andolini's Pizzeria Sliced Blue Dome serves pizza, gelato, and desserts in Tulsa, Oklahoma. Guests highlight homemade crust and oversized, cheesy slices, crispy fried mozzarella with marinara, and friendly service. The spot features a bar, online ordering, delivery, and takeout, with gelato favorites like crème brûlée.

Empire Slice House - Downtown Tulsa sits at 417 N Main St, Tulsa, OK 74103, in the Arts District. A spacious pizzeria and bar, it blends a NYC-style vibe with quirky murals and friendly staff. Guests can order by the slice or whole pies, with rotating slices and staples like three-cheese, pepperoni, and Notorious P.I.G. The house pink sauce and a robust beer menu add to a chill, welcoming atmosphere, next to Cain's.

La Roma Pizza in Tulsa at 6027 S Sheridan Rd offers pizza along with Lebanese-inspired dishes, including shawarma, cabbage rolls, and baklava. A family-owned restaurant praised for outstanding flavor, a warm atmosphere, and friendly service that makes guests feel like family. Reviewers call it the best pizza in town, with a memorable crust and generous Mediterranean flavors.