Ben Garelick Jewelers

Name: Ben Garelick Jewelers
Address: 5001 Transit Road, Buffalo, NY, 14221, US
Telephone: (716) 631-1584
Price range: $$$
Rating: 5

Ben Garelick Jewelers: Custom rings, trusted service, lasting value.

5(5 reviews)

jewelry-store

$$$

Directions Call Website

About

Ben Garelick Jewelers in Buffalo specializes in custom engagement rings, wedding bands, repairs, and a wide selection of fine jewelry. Customers praise a pressure-free, attentive team that listens, offers detailed renderings, and helps buyers stay within budget. Staff like Susan, Grace, Patty, and Peter guide each step with integrity and dependable service from consultation to final piece.

Photos

1 / 1

Location

5001 Transit Rd, Buffalo, NY 14221, USA

Get directions

Information

5001 Transit Road

Buffalo, NY, 14221

(716) 631-1584 www.bengarelick.com/

Is this your business?

Claim Ben Garelick Jewelers to manage your storefront, respond to reviews, and receive customer leads.

Services

Custom Jewelry Design

Personalized design services for engagement rings and fine jewelry, with detailed renderings and adjustments to match your vision.

Jewelry Repair and Restoration

Expert repair services, including ring resizing, stone setting, and restoration to make pieces look better than new.

Fine Jewelry Sales

A wide selection of high-quality rings, wedding bands, and accessories, featuring GIA-certified diamonds and premium materials.

Wholesale and Custom Orders

Wholesale options and custom creations tailored to specific needs, with budget-friendly pricing and no pressure to upsell.

Consultation and Appraisal

Personalized sit-down appointments with knowledgeable staff to guide you through selections, pricing, and care.

5.00 · 5 reviews

Overall rating

David Morris

via Google

· 10 months ago

I’ve worked with Ben Garelick Jewelers twice now, first for my fiancée’s engagement ring in 2024 and again this year for her matching wedding band. Both experiences were flawless. Peter took care of everything end to end. He helped me stay within my budget without cutting corners, walked me through every detail, and delivered a 3.00 carat E-color GIA stone that genuinely blew us away. The proposal was perfect because the ring was perfect. What impressed me most was how they operate. They rushed the engagement ring to hit a tight deadline, fixed a shipping address for me at the last minute, and kept communication tight the entire way. When I came back for the wedding band, Peter honored the original quoted price even after the retail price jumped. That’s rare these days. It tells you everything you need to know about their integrity and how they treat customers. We’re now two purchases in and both exceeded expectations. Quality, service, honesty, and follow-through. If you're looking for a jeweler you can trust with the biggest moments of your life, these are your people. I’d give them six stars if I could.

Madelyn Rossi

via Google

· 11 months ago

I could not have asked for a better experience or a more beautiful ring. My fiancé and I had a very specific vision for my ring, and they exceeded all of our expectations. Susan was so perceptive to what I wanted and made our sit down appointment a dream! Thank you Ben Garelick for my absolute dream ring. I could not be happier!

Jackie Haas-Anglen

via Google

· 1 year ago

I went to this jeweler as I needed my rings repaired after I had to have them cut off due to an allergic reaction to a yellow jacket sting. They did an incredible job! They honestly look better than when i first got them! I highly recommend going to them for all your jewelry needs.

Wendy Reynolds

via Google

· 1 year ago

This was such a wonderful, personable, pressure free experience. I was looking for an anniversary ring but I had something very specific in mind. I took advantage of the custom option and worked with Grace. She took the time to really listened to what I was looking for, provided detailed renderings, and adjusted as requested. Everything was completed within my price range, with no pressure to upsale. I loved working with her, and the product is even better than I imaged. Great experience! I will be buying from them again!

Dawn Zymowski

via Google

· 1 year ago

There was a large selection of beautiful rings. Party is amazing ... Friendly, knowledgeable and professional! It was an absolute pleasure working with her!!! My fiance and I picked out my engagement ring and our wedding bands with Patty's help and could not be happier with our choices. We were married in May 2025. Thank YOU Patty and Ben Garelick Jewelers! We will definitely be back 😃

More businesses like this

View details →

jewelry store

Williamsville, NY

Andrews Jewelers

Andrews Jewelers, located at 4715 Transit Rd, Williamsville, NY, is a jewelry store known for attentive, professional service. Reviews highlight staff member Sarah for listening, guidance, and care, whether resizing a ring quickly, crafting custom engagement rings, or repairing pieces. With a wide selection and quality craftsmanship, it delivers a trusted jewelry experience.

View details →

jewelry store

Depew, NY

Goldsmiths of WNY

Goldsmiths of WNY in Depew offers jewelry repairs, custom work, and watch maintenance. Loyal customers report fast, friendly service—rings fixed and polished in minutes, necklaces repaired when others couldn't, watch batteries replaced, and bracelets resized with care. Located at 6346 Transit Rd, Depew, NY 14043, USA, next to Transit Hill Pharmacy, the shop is known for fair pricing and dependable craftsmanship.

View details →

jewelry store

Scherer's Jewelers

Scherer's Jewelers in Amherst is a trusted jewelry store and gift shop, known for custom design and repair. With multiple 5/5-star reviews, customers praise patient, knowledgeable staff who explain diamond options, provide renderings, and guide decisions. From engagement rings to heirloom restorations, the team delivers warm, personal service and top-tier results.

View details →

jewelry store

Buffalo, NY

Bomi Jewelers

Bomi Jewelers, located at 4574 Main St in Buffalo, NY, offers a wide selection of jewelry, reliable repairs, and custom design options. Reviewers praise friendly, personalized service from Nikki, Erica, and Laura, with seamless engagement ring experiences and help finding great deals at reasonable prices. The shop exudes a welcoming, family-owned feel and can arrange catalog bands at no extra cost.

View details →

jewelry store

Buffalo, NY

Colosseum Jewelry

Colosseum Jewelry in Buffalo offers fast, friendly service with attentive staff who help shoppers find the right pieces quickly. Reviews highlight smooth, quick transactions, responsive answers, and good prices, along with a welcoming in-store experience at 1 Galleria Dr. Customers note memorable service and plan to return, making Colosseum Jewelry a trusted local jewelry store.

View details →

jewelry store

Buffalo, NY

Jared Jewelers

Jared Jewelers in Buffalo, NY, offers attentive, no-pressure service praised by customers for remembering details and treating shoppers like family. The Walden Ave store helps with jewelry inspections, upgrades (diamond and bezel settings), and wedding or engagement rings, plus special orders such as Citizen watches. The caring staff aim to deliver the best price and a welcoming, memorable experience.

Directions Call