Services Offered
Giant Pizza Slices
Huge, thin-crust slices with parmesan flavor, available for quick takeaway or dine-in.
Whole Pizzas
Massive 28-inch pizzas perfect for parties, events, or group gatherings.
Late-Night Dining
Open late to serve college crowds and night owls with fresh, hot pizza.
Catering & Party Orders
Large box orders for rehearsals, weddings, and events with efficient service.
Dine-In Experience
Cozy seating in a historic building with tall ceilings and friendly atmosphere.
Reviews
4.8(5 reviews)
Rating Distribution
5
4
4
1
3
0
2
0
1
0
A
Allegra Pierce
via Google
2 months ago
I ate here while visiting Pittsburgh for a wedding . The wedding hosts served Bennys large boxes of pizza at their rehearsal dinner and they are truly massive (I’d never seen them before being from out of town) , it was a great idea for a party. I came by the store in south side flats to grab a slice the next day. I ordered the Italian sausage slice. For the price ($6) it’s a great lunch option- very filling and tasty.
M
Matt Ruffellvia Google
3 months ago
Good thin crust pizza made from a large 28 inch pizza dough. It has a strong underlying parmesan flavor and pairs well with hot sauce. I wish the crust was a bit more firm. It reminds me of a typical college town pizza place that serves up slices all hours of the night. Most people would think it is average tasting pizza, but I bet the college crowd treasures it.
K
Keithvia Google
3 months ago
Benny Fiero's is no doubt fire 🔥! The slices are literally massive, the cheese the right balance of flavor and "feel", and the crust is thin and Goldilocks crispy, just right! The spot is a neat old building with tall ceilings and cozy window front seating. Good vibes and great customer service. Plus the prices are a steal, 6 bucks for what is easily 2.5 normal slices. Benny's is unforgettable, one slice and you're hooked!
S
Smokin' Barrel Barbequevia Google
5 months ago
Visiting Pittsburgh and had this on our list to try! So good! So worth it!!! Our crew devoured the biggest pizza we ever had! That ranch, so good!!
R
Ron Branch IIvia Google
9 months ago
The pizza was very good. Chewy crust, not too greasy, and the slices were HUGE. My son and I both ordered 2 slices of pepperoni, but we each were only able to eat one. Each slice was 6 bucks, which I thought was a good deal. The guys manning the counter were polite and helpful, and we got our pizza in under 10 minutes.
