Services Offered
Giant NY-Style Pizza Slices
Massive 14" slices, equivalent to 3 regular slices, served floppy and cheesy on two plates.
Specialty Pizzas
Unique creations like jerk chicken with bacon and Jamaica BBQ, or garlic mushroom, available by the slice or whole pie.
Takeout and Delivery
Convenient pickup and delivery options through platforms like DoorDash for enjoying our pizza at home.
Family Dining Experience
Casual, family-friendly atmosphere with arcade games in the backroom and old-timey sodas.
Breadsticks and Sides
Classic breadsticks and other sides to complement your pizza meal.
Reviews
4.2(5 reviews)
Rating Distribution
5
4
4
0
3
0
2
0
1
1
C
CL R
via Google
2 months ago
Trenton and Kate or Kaighton I think her full name is were truly amazing. They were so friendly and provided the best customer service that I have had in a very long time. This young man and young lady were so well mannered and provided first class service that put a smile on my face at the end of a long day. We cannot lose faith in this younger generation. These young people are evidence that there are still hard working and kindness in the world. Every business needs someone like them to keep customers coming back because of how they made me feel valued and appreciated for my business. Thank you both!!
V
Vanessa Cassibavia Google
5 months ago
Very large slices, delicious, and nice special flavors. I had one w jerk chicken, bacon, and a jamaica BBQ. My husband had garlic mushroom. They were both very tasty.
R
Randi sperlingvia Google
6 months ago
I will never understand why some make.pizzas this large when they OBVIOUSLY do not know how. Not only was 3/4 of it raw, there was no pepperoni and the onions and peppers are mushy. Like.....really gross mushy. A little bite to sauce but edible. The crust is the ONLY part of this gigantic pizza I will eat as it's the ONLY part of the pizza that is not mushy and Raw. $55 for a giant raw dough, mushy veggies amd zero pepperoni. Seriously? We do NOT recommend this pizza. Worst either of us has ever had.
J
James Kenningtonvia Google
8 months ago
A must try! Heard about the extra large slices, so we gave it a try. $6 for a slice of pepperoni, and trust me, 1 slice is enough. Floppy, cheesy, NY style 14" slices that come on 2 plates. Added breadsticks to top off the lunch. Will definitely revisit.
G
Gabrielle Whitevia Google
about 1 year ago
I've ordered for pickup through Door Dash and also ordered inside for takeout, and it's official: I love this place! The slices are HUGE and about the equivalent of 3 regular slices from other places and ridiculously delicious. The staff was very knowledgeable about their production process and the atmosphere is family friendly. Even though they were slammed busy they treated every customer with patience and professionalism. The owner should be proud! Also, they have those old timey like sodas and a backroom FULL of arcade games. I'm pretty sure Benny's is going to become a locals' favorite. 10/10 would HIGHLY recommend!
