Bitten Cupcakes, Butter Tarts & Cookie Tacos

Located in Hamilton, MySweeTooth is a welcoming bakery and cake shop offering fresh, beautifully presented treats. Customers praise not-too-sweet flavors—from matcha desserts and mochi to a variety of cakes—and note friendly, attentive staff and a cozy, clean space. The owner and team craft wedding cakes and provide online ordering for celebrations and everyday delights.

Ola Bakery & Pastry, Hamilton blends a welcoming Portuguese-inspired cafe and bakery at 230 James St N. Guests rave about fresh pastries like natas and lemon turnovers, generous sandwiches on fresh buns, and tasty soups. The cozy space offers plenty of seating, friendly, helpful staff, fair prices, and an authentic vibe with easy parking behind the shop.

Dear Grain in Hamilton specializes in sourdough-based breads and a rotating lineup of baked goods, from croissants and cookies to scones. Located at 103 Vine St, the pick-up only bakery attracts visitors with crusty country-style loaves and friendly, helpful service. Reviewers praise the quality, flavor, and value of each treat.

Bonanza Bakery in Hamilton offers fresh deli sandwiches, pastries, buns, and ready-to-eat options at 100 Murray St E. Customers praise fresh ingredients, generous portions, friendly, knowledgeable staff, and clean surroundings at reasonable prices. The shop is take-out only, with limited street parking and some nearby free parking. Reviews note no credit card surcharge and no free WiFi; one mentions changes under a new owner.

Weil's Bakery in Hamilton offers a broad range of baked goods, from wedding cakes and donuts to carrot cake, lemon cake, and vanilla with raspberry buttercream. Reviewers praise Isabel for prompt service and for helping realize wedding visions, including matching florals. The menu includes pies, pastries, croissants, scones, sticky buns, breads, and more for takeout or pre-order. Street and lot parking, plus indoor accessibility.

La Bakeri is celebrated as one of Hamilton's last true Italian bakeries, offering handmade, wholesome pastries that are not too sweet but full of flavor. Customers praise warm, welcoming service and a thoughtful selection, including gluten-free options. The bakery is a local gem, even trusted for special occasions like wedding cakes.