Authentic Italian dining and signature pizzas in downtown Milwaukee.
Calderone Club - Downtown Milwaukee serves authentic Italian cuisine, from veal parmigiano and rigatoni to oblong-crust pizzas. Located at 842 N Old World 3rd St, Milwaukee, it is praised for famous meatballs, cannoli, and house salads with creamy Italian dressing. Guests commend attentive service (noting Luis) and bar or sidewalk seating, along with a superb pizza crust.
842 N Old World 3rd St, Milwaukee, WI 53203, USA
Claim Calderone Club - Downtown Milwaukee to manage your storefront, respond to reviews, and receive customer leads.
Enjoy authentic dishes like Veal Parmigiano, Rigatoni, and house-made meatballs in an upscale setting.
Try our famous oblong-shaped pizzas with fresh toppings, including off-menu sliced meatballs.
Sip on expertly crafted cocktails and a curated selection of wines to complement your meal.
Indulge in traditional desserts like cannoli, paired with Italian coffee for a perfect finish.
Host events or gatherings with our attentive service and customizable menu options.
Overall rating
Alex H
I tried this place for the first time and I couldn't believe I hadn't been here sooner. The food was great, we got the garlic bread and caprese to start. We tried the famous meatballs (they were delicious) and I ordered the tortellini. Cocktails were just okay but I would definitely go back.
Chris Diddit
Random walk in met with a seat at the bar or a lone corner table on the sidewalk so of course I chose to check out the scenery which didn’t disappoint. I started with the salad and ranch which was light and fresh along with some house made ranch dressing. The NY strip was perfectly cooked and just the right amount of flavor which was accompanied by a vegetable medley. The bread came out with softened butter and was perfect for cleaning my plates. Luis was definitely a veteran and took great care of me. Was it worth it? Yes sirrrrr!
Ω
Absolutely a great experience. I say experience because you're not just there for a classic Milwaukee pizza. I think they may have other Italian offerings as well. (The other dishes look great, but I was there for the pizza) I like the oblong shape and the crust is superb. This isn't a NYC slice to walk around with, it's a different style and it's a classic recipe still being made today for a reason. The sliced meatballs I got as a topping are not on the menu, but are not to be missed. I think the additional charge was effectively for a side of meatballs, but absolutely worth it. I had a slice of a friend's pepperoni and that doesn't disappoint.
Brian Kaminski
The was delish. We had the Calerone special which is pizza with the works, the house salad with creamy Italian dressing and I had the cannoli. The only complaint was that it got very loud inside as people where coming in. W my parents and I arrived shortly after it opened.
RICK
There aren't many words to explain how phenomenal my meal was. I ordered the Veal Parmigiano with a Rigatoni and a side of meatballs. Everything was delicious and authentic. For dessert I decided on the cannoli with an Italian coffee. I haven't had Italian food this good at a restaurant in a very long time. Our waiter was great and very attentive. I wish I Iived a bit closer because I would definitely be back. Don't miss our on this place if you want a delicious Italian meal.
