Eat the Best Pizza: Fresh slices, bold flavors, and a welcoming vibe.
Eat the Best Pizza is a Madison pizza restaurant at 711 State Street. Diners praise crispy crusts, flavorful pies, and the option to grab a slice, with favorites like margarita and supreme. Reviewers also note friendly, attentive staff and a welcoming owner. The menu features buffalo chicken and BBQ chicken pizzas, garlic knots, and baklava, with late hours noted by customers.
711 State Street, 711 State St, Madison, WI 53703, USA
Claim Eat the Best Pizza to manage your storefront, respond to reviews, and receive customer leads.
Freshly baked pizza slices available daily, with rotating flavors like margarita and supreme.
Customizable whole pizzas with a variety of toppings, perfect for groups or takeout.
House-made garlic knots, a customer favorite known for their outstanding flavor and texture.
Unique options such as buffalo chicken and BBQ chicken pizza, made with fresh ingredients.
Sweet treats including baklava, perfect for ending your meal on a high note.
Open late to serve hungry customers looking for a quick, delicious bite after hours.
Overall rating
Norman Martin
Pizza was delicious. I had a slice of the margarita and it was awesome. I also tried the supreme. The crust is nice and crispy with a really good flavor. And it's nice to have the option to get slices. The owner was really nice. The baklava is delicious!!
Nestly Hoeg
I picked this place because it had decent reviews and I was really in the mood for good pizza. The price was pretty high, but I figured it was downtown and maybe it would be a hidden gem or something like that. If you want to “eat the best pizza “, go somewhere else. This is quite literally worse than a little Caesars hot and ready…. reheated it after it’s been in the fridge for a day. (that’s an all-time low for me.) The pizza tasted like it was under a heat lamp all day, thin and absolutely tasteless. I could not believe I paid that much money for something so shitty. They weren’t able to deliver so we drove in a snowstorm to get there. It was hard to find, surprised it was in a little basement area. And the kid that was working there alone looked like he was doing his homework at a booth, selling the rest of day old pizza that was left for the night. It’s clear this place was made for college students who are in a hurry and too busy to notice. Don’t waste your time or money.
Jerry Murphy
We had three pieces of pizza and soda and the garlic knots. Two of the three slices were OK. The third was overcooked. But the garlic knots were OUTSTANDING. I would go back just for them.
Besa
Stopped by for the first time and was really impressed! The owner is super friendly and went above and beyond to make sure we had a great experience. We tried the buffalo chicken pizza, garlic knots, and BBQ chicken pizza—all fresh, flavorful, and delicious. Perfect spot for a quick bite, and I love that they’re open late too. Definitely coming back!
Isaac Mullikin
I’ve been coming to Eat The Best for the past 4 years, and I can honestly say the name couldn’t be more fitting. The food is always so good. What makes this place stand out even more is the people. The staff has always been nothing but amazing to me. Friendly, welcoming, and they go out of their way to make sure every visit is a great one. It’s rare to find a spot that nails both the food and the experience, but Eat The Best does it every time. If you’re looking for a pizza place that you’ll keep coming back to year after year, this is it. Highly recommend!
