FP
Fellini's Pizza
Fellini's Pizza: NYC-style pies with fresh dough and sauce in a relaxed Atlanta neighborhood hub.
4.4
Pizza
$
Fellini's Pizza: NYC-style pies with fresh dough and sauce in a relaxed Atlanta neighborhood hub.
Located at 909 Ponce De Leon Ave NE in Atlanta, Fellini's Pizza serves authentic, NYC-style pies with dough and sauce made in-house. The casual, retro-looking neighborhood spot delivers solid crusts and fresh toppings, offering a welcoming, non-chain pizza experience for locals and visitors alike.
No photos available
Fresh, hot slices with house-made dough and sauce, available in classic toppings like pepperoni and supreme.
Customizable whole pizzas baked to order, featuring thick crusts and high-quality ingredients for dine-in or takeout.
Selection of draft beers, including Peroni, to complement your pizza in a relaxed setting.
Fresh salads and sides to round out your meal, served with generous portions.
Laid-back, retro atmosphere perfect for quick lunches, family dinners, or hanging out with friends.
Claim Fellini's Pizza to update business info, respond to reviews, and access analytics.
Overall rating
Ray Dude
I've eaten that Fellini's pizza for many years every time it's quite consistent and seems to be fresh. Obviously they make their own dough and sauce that is quite evident. This location did not disappoint. I met with my oldest daughter who lives in Grant Park and we talked for hours. I had two peroni draft beers, which were great addition to their pizza. Overall, I highly recommend this pizza company to anybody who wants authentic fresh pizza and not a chain.
Marc Jones
Came here on a lunch break with my co-workers. They had mentioned how good it was and how it was like pizza from NYC. Being from NYC, I just had to try it out. I ordered two slices with pepperoni, extra cheese and jalapenos. It was very good! It was the closest to pizza back home than most places in the Atlanta area that I've had so far. Cheese was melted good, dough was baked enough to fold and hold and it tasted great! If you moved from NYC or just visiting and you're looking for that NYC pizza experience, try this place out. You may like it!
DMarie
My favorite pizza place in Atlanta. I love the thick crust pizza and an atmosphere that screams ATL!! This place is even endorsed by Spiderman (all 3 of them). 🤣🤣
True Believer
The pizza was nice, tasty for real. The salad 🥗 was really good except they went crazy with the olives 😲 Worth a visit.
Que The Traveler
It definitely has an old retro look to it, but the food was pretty damn good. I had a slice of pepperoni and a slice of supreme, both served hot with just the right amount of crisp on the crust. The sauce had that classic, slightly sweet taste that reminded me of old-school pizzerias, and the cheese was perfectly melted—not too greasy, just flavorful and fresh. The staff was laid-back but attentive, and the overall vibe was relaxed, like a neighborhood spot that doesn’t try too hard because it doesn’t have to. It’s not fancy, but that’s part of its charm. If you’re looking for a casual place to grab solid pizza without all the extra fluff, Fellini’s on Ponce is definitely worth stopping by.
