Glass Nickel Pizza Co. - Madison East

It's Good For You serves wood-fired pizza with a crisp crust and generous toppings in Madison, paired with a welcoming, family-style vibe. Customers praise delicious flavors, friendly service, and a warm patio that's dog-friendly. Owner Alessandro, a Sicily-born host, adds authenticity and aperitifs such as Amaro, limoncello, and a rhubarb-cello. The team also offers catering with a wood-fired pizza oven set up in driveways for events, with on-time service and polished presentation.

Grampa's Pizzeria in Madison (1374 Williamson St) serves creative, thin-crust pizzas with fresh ingredients. Customers praise crispy crusts, flavorful sauces, and generous toppings, plus standout dishes like roasted veggies and curry squash. The welcoming atmosphere and friendly service keep guests coming back for a casual, inviting dining experience.

Salvatore's Tomato Pies - Madison serves Italian-style pizzas in 10" and 16" sizes, with gluten-free crusts available. The menu pairs rotating seasonal flavors with staples, and features a full bar with cocktails. Guests praise attentive, friendly service, a cozy neon-lit atmosphere, and easy parking in the adjacent garage. The venue is popular for groups and Wednesday trivia nights.

Molten Monkey is a Madison pizza restaurant at 912 E Johnson St, famous for Detroit-style pies with crispy cheese edges and tangy crust. Guests rave about Monkey Styx with Monkey Sauce and other flavors like Piggly Figgly, Big Chungus, and Chicken Bacon Ranch. Reviews applaud flavorful pizzas and warm hospitality from Otto, making dine-in or takeout memorable.

Lucille is a downtown Madison pizza restaurant located at 101 King St. Customer reviews praise its bold pizzas, including vegetarian and gluten-free options, and a standout cheese pull. The lively retro décor and attentive staff create a welcoming atmosphere for meals or drinks, even during busy hours.

Ian’s Pizza Madison | State Street sits at 100 State St, Madison, WI 53703, offering bold, creative pies including Mac and Cheese and BBQ Chicken Bacon Ranch, with vegan and vegetarian options. The lively venue supports dine-in, delivery, catering, and takeout. Reviews praise wide choices, crispy thin crust, and friendly, reliable service.