GP
Good Pizza
Good Pizza: NYC-style slices that shine in Cleveland.
5
Pizza
$$
Good Pizza: NYC-style slices that shine in Cleveland.
Good Pizza offers NYC-style pizza at 2057 E 4th St, Cleveland. Diners praise a light, crisp crust with the right char, aged dough, and a fresh, flavorful sauce. Favorites include specialty pies like vodka sauce and a margherita, with some noting hot honey and basil for a flavor boost. The casual, slice-shop vibe complements the strong pizza and attentive service.
No photos available
Freshly baked slices with aged dough, charred crust, and a variety of sauces like vodka and classic tomato.
Customizable whole pies available for dine-in or takeout, featuring premium toppings and specialty options.
Unique creations such as pepperoni with hot honey and basil, or seasonal specials that highlight innovative flavors.
Convenient online ordering for quick pickup, perfect for enjoying our pizza at home or on the go.
Large orders for events and gatherings, bringing our acclaimed pizza to your special occasions.
Overall rating
Heather G.
Just having landed in CLE, I was looking for some fabulous pizza. To me, NY style pizza is what is fabulous. So, I looked up some reviews and made my way to Good Pizza. I went on a weekday at lunchtime and it wasn't busy. I asked the person working some questions about the sauce options and went with one of the special pizzas with vodka sauce. It was delicious. Beyond just delicous. There was love in that slice. The little pizza spot is super cute and well decorated. I would not come here for an evening out at a pizzeria... it's not that vibe. But the vibe is lit for a little pizza slice place.
Victor Ceicys
We drove in from Cleveland Heights tonight, 12/02/2025, on a cold winter's night for an on-line ordered Margherita for pick-up, quickly drove home, and as we came in through the door, we both first had an untouched slices (very good), followed by slight rewarmed slices at 225F, and then we were absolutely delighted with the pizza. This is a real authentic NYC style of pizza here in Cleveland. The thin crust was outstanding, with an amazing texture, even better when rewarmed, but the freshness and clarity of the sauce was even better. My wife and I love NYC pizzas, but the sauce was a phenomenal treat. My wife couldn't stop raving about how good the sauce "made the pizza" complementing the great crust. Charlie has given us all in here in Cleveland a real pizza treasure. We're hooked and will have more in the future.
Patrick Ramsey
I’ve eaten numerous times at the highest rated pizza spots all over NYC and I can honestly say “Good Pizza” needs to change their name to “Great Pizza” or maybe, just maybe “The Best Pizza”. I thought the pizza looked good seeing the pictures and videos, but truly blown away having my first slice, then another slice, then the slice my son didn’t finish…”Good Pizza” can match up and go head to head with any pizza I’ve ever had the pleasure to eat in my lifetime. Great, Great Pizza! Service was A+++ as well.
Andrew Miner
Awesome pizza. Everything is perfect. Quite possibly the best pizza I have ever had. The bottom crust has the perfect amount of char. The sauce tastes fresh and flavorful but is not distracting. The crust is made from an aged dough and delicious the perfect texture. The cheese is perfect in terms of quantity and quality. It’s such a light and delicious pizza too. 10/10
Douglas Beam
A refreshingly new and yet totally recognizable take on the pepperoni pizza. Their crust is fantastically light and crisp, and the combination of the hot honey and basil adds an explosion of flavor. We’re not from Cleveland and we wish we could get a slice closer to our home! Strongly recommend for anyone local or anyone just passing through!
Claim Good Pizza to update business info, respond to reviews, and access analytics.
