C

Colby Lindsayvia Google

about 2 months ago

Absolutely amazing! They literally made me look forward to my next trip to OKC! The corn arrancini app is fantastic. The lasagna was to die for

R

RealEstateWithRanavia Google

3 months ago

Outstanding hospitality from start to finish. The host, waitstaff, chefs, and manager were all wonderful. Warm ambiance, delicious food, and an unforgettable tiramisu.

D

Derrick Quigleyvia Google

4 months ago

My wife and I went to Mary Eddy’s for a local date night, and we absolutely loved it. The restaurant has such an intimate, cozy atmosphere with a great vibe — perfect for a night out. The ambiance and service were spot-on, and the food was excellent from start to finish. Definitely one of the better date night spots in OKC. We’ll be back for sure!

J

Jill Chafitzvia Google

8 months ago

Mary Eddy's delivers an exceptional dining experience that perfectly balances upscale Italian cuisine with a warm, inviting atmosphere. Located in a beautifully restored space with unique modern industrial decor, the restaurant creates an ambiance that's both chic and comfortable. Food & Presentation: Every dish was expertly crafted and beautifully presented. The bone-in ribeye was cooked to perfection - tender, flavorful, and accompanied by a rich, savory sauce that complemented the meat beautifully. The pasta dish featured perfectly al dente noodles in a vibrant, well-balanced sauce with fresh herbs and quality cheese that elevated every bite. The appetizer spread was equally impressive, featuring artisanal bread with a trio of house-made sauces and what appeared to be a creative take on bruschetta with rich, caramelized toppings and fresh burrata. Cocktails: The bar program is top-notch, with expertly crafted cocktails that show attention to detail in both flavor and presentation. Each drink was perfectly balanced and beautifully garnished. Atmosphere: The converted factory space features stunning architectural details, vintage artwork, and thoughtful lighting that creates an intimate yet sophisticated dining environment. The "chill vibe" mentioned in their description is spot-on - it's upscale without being stuffy. Overall: Mary Eddy's Italian Grill successfully delivers on its promise of "New American eats & cocktails" in a unique setting. The combination of exceptional food quality, creative presentation, skilled bartending, and distinctive atmosphere makes this a standout dining destination. The 4.4-star rating is well-deserved, and I'd highly recommend it for both special occasions and elevated casual dining. Highly recommended for anyone seeking a memorable Italian-inspired dining experience! Shot out to our Server : Caitrin

M

misty wakefieldvia Google

8 months ago

Love the atmosphere. Service was good. Food wasn’t what I expected from an Italian spot, but it was good also. Loved the bread spread, shrimp was good quality. Blue crab campanelle was very good, perfect Al dente pasta with a kick and the sweet crab and breadcrumbs. Loved the broccolini, and pork chops were tender. Both had a good grill/smoky taste. Drink menu wasn’t for me and we weren’t going to get dessert (because I always compare my tiramisu 😭) but it was on the house for our celebration. It was good. I was skeptical because of the non traditional cookie used but I’d have it again. Parking was confusing because we didn’t realize to just valet (complimentary of you dine in) but all the staff were very helpful.