MN
Michael's New York Style Pizza
A true New York-style slice right in Stockton.
4.2
Pizza
$$
A true New York-style slice right in Stockton.
Michael's New York Style Pizza in Stockton, located at 2300 W Alpine Ave, offers classic New York–style pies, takeout and delivery, and a menu praised for quality ingredients. Reviewers highlight fast, friendly service, inventive monthly specials (including dill pickle combos), and a welcoming atmosphere with big-screen TVs. The long‑standing pizza joint has supported the community with charity events and features favorites like The Greek and pear with gorgonzolla pizza, plus a full bar and standout ranch.
No photos available
Hand-tossed pizzas with quality toppings, including classic and creative monthly specials.
Convenient ordering for pickup or delivery to enjoy our pizza at home or on the go.
Family-friendly restaurant with full bar, big-screen TVs, and welcoming atmosphere.
Pizza catering for parties, fundraisers, and community events with customizable options.
Enjoy drinks from our bar while watching sports or dining with friends and family.
Claim Michael's New York Style Pizza to update business info, respond to reviews, and access analytics.
Overall rating
Jory Gwasdoff
Michael’s pizza is great! If you want quality ingredients on a really good pizza, there’s really only a few places in town that do it well and Michael’s pizza is one of them that’s been doing it for 47 years. I admit I don’t go often because it’s pretty far away from where I live, but I’m always happy with the food and service and would definitely recommend to others.
Larry Dillard
This place has great pizza and some of their monthly special are weird combos, but we recently had one which included dill pickles and it was great. We normally get take out, but have seen many people enjoying football on the big screen TVs. We found this place since they donated food at Pixie Woods (children park) fund raiser the last few years. I highly recommend this place. If you're in a hurry, call your order in advance then head over.
Jeff Cherukara
This pizza place is absolutely incredible! I finally got to try this historic pizza place that's been around forever as I was driving through the city. The service was outstanding – fast, friendly, and attentive. And the food... wow. This is hands down the best pizza I've ever had. Seriously, every bite was amazing. I even met the owner's son, Kyle, and he was the man! Pro tip: their ranch is out of this world, truly the best I've ever tasted. They also have a full bar, and the prices were surprisingly amazing for such high quality. This is definitely my new pizza spot anytime I come through the city! I highly recommend it!
Mary Coffey
I usually order The Greek pizza. This time I tried the pear with gorganzolla pizza. I enjoyed the variety and mix of flavors. I would get it again. The way this place feels is nice. Good everything.
Bill Everitt
I'm so sorry I didn't read the reviews but I've always considered Michael's the best in town, evidently no longer. The crust was flat and tasteless, lacked the usual amount of cheese, and most ingredients were all in the center which I tried to spread out. Overall it was bland, and I added garlic. I tried calling to talk to the manager but evidently they didn't have the time to talk to me. Might just be the last time I order from Michael's! Doesn't deserve the one star I had to give!
