PM
Pizza Man on Downer
Milwaukee's beloved Italian eatery, serving artisanal pizzas and fine wines in a cozy, jazz-filled atmosphere.
4.8(5 reviews)
$$
italian
italian
Enjoy handcrafted pizzas with crispy crusts and premium toppings, including signature options like the Atomico and Topher, served in a cozy, jazz-filled setting.
Savor homemade pastas, such as carbonara and ravioli, along with other Italian classics like grilled calamari and apple salads, made with fresh ingredients.
Explore an extensive wine list and curated cocktail selections, with expert server recommendations to complement your meal for a perfect dining experience.
Relax to live jazz music in our mood-lit interior or dine al fresco on the upstairs patio deck, overlooking Downer Avenue for a scenic evening out.
Join exclusive events like whiskey pairing dinners, featuring thoughtfully plated dishes and insights from passionate chefs, ideal for celebrations or unique nights out.
Milwaukee's beloved Italian eatery, serving artisanal pizzas and fine wines in a cozy, jazz-filled atmosphere.
No photos available
Pizza Man on Downer is a cherished Milwaukee institution, offering an authentic Italian dining experience with a focus on artisanal pizzas, handmade pastas, and an extensive wine selection. Located in the heart of the Downer Avenue neighborhood, our restaurant combines a relaxed, mood-lit ambiance with live jazz music and exceptional service. Whether you're enjoying a romantic dinner, gathering with friends on our scenic upstairs patio, or attending one of our special whiskey pairing events, we pride ourselves on delivering memorable meals and warm hospitality. With a 4.7-star rating and a loyal following, we're dedicated to crafting delicious, high-quality dishes that keep our community coming back.
Receive attentive and friendly service from our dedicated staff, including personalized wine suggestions and a welcoming atmosphere that enhances your visit.
My husband and I went with 2 other couples to the whiskey pairing dinner on December 23, and it was impeccable! The plating was just as thoughtful as the dishes. The chef and sous chef have so much passion for their craft and that was clear. Can't wait to return! Looking out for their special events, too!
I’ve been dining at Pizza Man since the North Ave. days. Tonight, we had the pleasure of having Justin as our server. Loved the energy and the wine suggestion. Wished they could’ve pulled up a chair to enjoy the bottle together. An all around fabulous meal. Thank you for the hospitality! We love Pizza Man.
A lovely and delicious meal at Pizza Man. This was our first time dining in since they closed this location and moved back. The ambiance is very relaxing, with mood lighting and live jazz. The service was exceptional. My apple salad was perfect as was my wine selection. I'm very happy Pizza Man is back in the neighborhood and will be back soon!
It's been a minute since we've eaten at the reknown Pizza Man. The 2025 experience was mixed with a renovated interior really keeping this business relevant. The food was simply not worth the price, or maybe I'm just just not a fan of the ingredients on the atomico pizza. The crust was crispy and the pizza did feel light which I appreciate but the sopressata, Calabrian pepper combo just didn't quite balance itself out and tasted a bit off. The carbonara pasta was also out of balance, tasting a bit too salty but maybe I'm not a huge pancetta fan after all. I suspect we would have enjoyed other items on the menu like the Topher or the ravioli. But who knows! The grilled calamari was good, but quite portions were small. I would recommend visiting for the upstairs patio deck alone, which overlooks Downer Ave. You could tell that everyone sitting there was really lingering and enjoying every moment of a beautiful summer evening.
My girlfriend and I came in for dinner and a drink. The truffle fries were good, would definitely get again. The pizza was also good, some of the best in Milwaukee. The only thing that was better than the food was the service! Megan took care of us and it was the best service I have gotten in Milwaukee. I will definitely be back and will ask for Megan to be our server again!
Claim Pizza Man on Downer to update business info, respond to reviews, and access analytics.
