Pizza Shack Slice House

Venezia's Pizzeria in Mesa serves New York-style pizza with large, foldable slices and a menu of wings and salads. The spot is known for fast, hot, on-point orders—even during busy rushes—thanks to a crispy-chewy crust. Options range from 12" to 24" pies, with the popular wings and a golden medium wing sauce. Reviews praise friendly staff, easy online ordering, and a lively, family-owned setting with outdoor seating.

Buono's Pizza Higley in Gilbert offers a welcoming sit-down experience with pizza, wings, salads, arancini, and calzones. Guests praise friendly service from Rob, Claire, and Katie, a cozy atmosphere, and crispy crusts with generous portions. Described by guests as family-owned and operated, it features specialty pies and reliable, flavorful favorites.

Salerno's in Gilbert serves Chicago-style tavern pizza alongside lasagna, garlic bread, and homemade minestrone. Customers praise the use of high-quality ingredients and pies served piping hot, even for take-out. The restaurant exudes a welcoming, family-style vibe with friendly staff and a neighborhood feel, featuring counter-ordering and a focus on consistent, flavorful dishes.

Located at 1665 S Stapley Dr, Mesa, Mellow Mushroom Mesa serves pizza, vegetarian and vegan options, sandwiches, catering, and delivery. Reviews highlight a clean, inviting space with a roomy bar, friendly staff, and a lively vibe. Popular picks include Holy Shiitake Mushroom Pizza, Elevated Cobb Salad, Greek salad, and artichoke dip. Open for dine-in, takeout, and delivery.

Fire & Brimstone Pizza Restaurant in Gilbert delivers wood-fired, brick-oven pizzas in a lively complex of shops and a brewery. Outdoor seating with misters keeps guests comfortable, while counter service delivers pizzas to tables. Fans praise Cesar salad and butternut squash soup, plus pizzas like carnivore, prosciutto and fig, and buffalo chicken, all crafted from high-quality ingredients.

Organ Stop Pizza in Mesa offers more than pizza: a giant Wurlitzer pipe organ dominates the two-story dining room, rising and playing a wide repertoire as guests request songs. Patrons order at the counter, enjoy a salad bar, and choose from pizzas, pastas, drinks, and ice cream. Upstairs seating and ample parking make it a family-friendly, entertaining dining experience.