Freshly baked or reheated slices of our signature thin-crust pizzas, perfect for a quick bite.
Order a full pizza with your choice of toppings, ideal for sharing or takeaway.
Freshly fried sides like garlic knots and cheese sticks to complement your meal.
Special offers like slices with knots and a drink for great value.
Enjoy your pizza hot at our cozy joint or take it to go for convenience.
Wait 20 mins for a fresh pizza to come out or get a reheated slice (base is a bit hard). It’s ok.
I’m from New York living in Sydney for over 30 years. I’ve been waiting years for a New York Slice of pizza and now Sals is the go to.. it taste just like from NY. Sals proves the pizza is better in New York is not because of the water! It’s because of his craft!
Fear not when you see the pizzas getting reheated. My goodness, they tasted as if they were fresh out of the oven after a quick revival. I think it is best eaten at the joint, not takeaway. The pepperoni is a must. This was honestly the best NY style pizza I’ve ever eaten in Australia. Cheese sticks are also freshly fried and delicious. Can’t wait to come back again to try the other pizzas!
Was an ok experience. Pizza slices were old and re heated so the crust was very hard. Pizza sauce was nice and toppings weren’t bad. Garlic knots were just very doughy, minimal garlic, dry definitely have had better. Ranch sauce was horrible! $2.50 for a small tub of watered down sauce. Definitely is not ranch sauce, had no flavour at all. Don’t reccomend! Overall wouldn’t go back.
Happy we walked here. The restaurant was busy at 7pm Sunday night. We shared the special for $19 you get two slices of pizza and two knots with a can of soda. If you like thin crust pizza with lots of flavor, this place is for you. By the slice or the whole pie is offered. We tried the Hawaiian and Brooklyn. Excellent!! My husband had the knots, he liked them. I wish they had salad. Also wings are offered. We would definitely go back.

Taste of the Big Apple in Sydney – Authentic NY-style pizza by the slice or pie!
No photos available
Sal's Authentic New York Pizza brings a genuine taste of New York to Sydney's York Street. We specialize in classic, thin-crust NY-style pizzas, available by the slice or whole pie, made with high-quality ingredients and traditional techniques. Whether you're grabbing a quick lunch, a late-night snack, or feeding a group, our cozy spot offers a slice of home for locals and expats alike. With rave reviews from New Yorkers themselves, we pride ourselves on delivering that iconic, foldable pizza experience right in the heart of Sydney.
Claim Sal's Authentic New York Pizza - York St to update business info, respond to reviews, and access analytics.