Silver In the City: Sparkling gifts, jewelry, and delightful finds on Massachusetts Ave
Silver In the City is a gift shop, jewelry store, and home goods store at 434 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46204. It features jewelry, stickers, bags, magnets, tarot cards, candles, books, car fresheners, and other gifts. Reviewers praise friendly, inviting service and a rewards program, a broad, curated selection, and a welcoming, inclusive vibe; jewelry is high-quality, sometimes pricey but worth it, especially for holidays.
434 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46204, USA
Claim Silver In the City to manage your storefront, respond to reviews, and receive customer leads.
A wide selection of unique, high-quality rings, necklaces, and other accessories, perfect for personal wear or gifting.
Curated collection of quirky trinkets, stickers, magnets, tarot cards, and candles for all occasions.
Stylish and functional items like bags, decor, and seasonal collections to enhance your living space.
Earn points on purchases to save on future visits, making shopping more rewarding for loyal customers.
Special holiday and Christmas-themed items, updated regularly to offer fresh, festive options.
Overall rating
Elaina Owens
They have nice stuff in there but if you are a POC you will not enjoy your experience. As soon as I came in they everything I looked at they wanted to hold it at the front for me and I kept getting stares as I shopped finally I just went to check out and I was the only person they were “holding “ stuff for very uncomfortable experience will not be back.
Rebecca Waletich
Always fun to shop their unique inventory.
Kayte H
Morgan L
My sister and I came here(we’re from out of town) and we were the only POC in the store and one of the employees walked up to just me, while I was looking at jewelry asking if I needed help finding anything and after I was done trying on rings, I looked up and noticed she had been watching me the entire time.
yadira
I never miss a chance to visit when I’m in the area. I absolutely love this store! jewelry that lasts, adorable trinkets, and the funniest/relatable stickers for my junk journal :))
Katharine White
I have come here many times for gifts and have always loved coming here. Today, my best friend and I came in to shop for matching jewelry. We spent a lot of time in the jewelry section trying on different rings, to make sure they fit both of us and we could see how they looked on us. We both wanted the perfect rings and we often take a lot of time browsing when we shop. We were talked to a few times by employees, but it was evident they suspected we may shoplift and were trying to interrupt our shopping and conversations. Additionally, there was always an employee very close to us, watching what we were doing. We were not fully done browsing yet when an employee stated “I can take that ring and hold it upfront for you.” She did not give me a choice, and also did not make my friend give her the ring. We browsed for another 5 minutes before feeling obligated to checkout, since my ring was at the register. I understand that it is not uncommon for college-aged girls to shoplift, but the way we were treated did significantly impact our shopping experience, especially since we were trying to pick out a sentimental piece of jewelery. I have come here many times both alone and with my teenage sister, and have never felt followed or watched closely by the employees.
