SI
Silver in the City - Carmel
Unique gifts and jewelry with Indiana-made charm in Carmel.
4(5 reviews)
Retail Store
$$
Unique gifts and jewelry with Indiana-made charm in Carmel.
Silver in the City - Carmel sits at 111 W Main St, Suite 150, Carmel, IN, offering a curated mix of gifts, jewelry, and home goods. Visitors praise the friendly staff and a broad selection of unique items, many made in Indiana, including stones, journals, bookmarks, and stickers. The store cultivates a welcoming, browsing-friendly atmosphere; however, some reviews note jewelry durability concerns.
No photos available
Handcrafted and unique jewelry pieces, including bracelets, rings, and anklets, with a focus on local Indiana artisans.
Curated gifts such as journals, bookmarks, stickers, and home decor, ideal for special occasions or personal treats.
A selection of goods made in Indiana, supporting local craftspeople and offering authentic Hoosier charm.
Decorative items for walls and tables, including fancy stuff and unique home accents to enhance your space.
Friendly and helpful staff available to guide you through our collection and answer questions about products.
My first time in carmel and walked by this shop with my mom. The staff were super friendly and fantastic. All were super helpful in everything I asked regarding jewelry. If you’re visiting Carmel stop by and show support. You get a variety of everything and all unique gifts mainly made in Indiana. Will definitely visit again
I’ve genuinely loved shopping at Silver in the City over the years. The staff is always warm, welcoming, and fun to interact with—it’s one of those places that makes browsing feel like a treat. That said, I’m giving 3 stars because of the quality of some of the jewelry I’ve purchased. This is the second time a bracelet has come apart, and I’ve had to replace a gold ring and a gold anklet due to tarnishing. I understand that not everything can last forever, but considering the price point, I expected better durability. It’s disappointing to invest in pieces that don’t hold up over time. I’ll continue to stop in for gifts and the great atmosphere, but I’ll be more cautious about the jewelry moving forward.
Our first visit to Carmel and we really enjoyed this store. We spend a long time looking at all the fun stuff. Bought a gift and a free things for myself including a fun total eclipse 2024 item.
I’m sure I’ll go back, because it’s a fun little store, but I didn’t appreciate the part, where my 8 year old daughter, and I were happily looking at some stuff and suddenly being stalked by one of the workers like we were abt to start stealing. I get people steal, and it’s probably an issue, but I’ve lived in Carmel my whole 50 years, and not interested in taking up a life of crime at this point. It’s insulting and makes for a bad shopping experience. Definitely changed my mind at spending any money there that night for sure.
Ok now this is what I call “The stuff dreams are made of!!!!”. Just a chance visit while strolling around Arts district and my goodness Silver in the city has the cutest, prettiest, bestest (I know that’s not a word) and awesome collection of stones, jewelry, journals, book marks, oh and the stickers!!!, you name it! I don’t even have the complete list here. What we planned as 2 mins ended up into a 20 minute dive into Silver in the City world and trust me, so trust me that I wasn’t done yet but I had to head out just then. This one’s a keeper for anyone who wants unique and different gifts, for anyone who likes to hoard journals and for anyone who loves adoring their walls and tables with fancy stuff. Ah I could go on and go on but you get the gist! Go, go now!
Claim Silver in the City - Carmel to update business info, respond to reviews, and access analytics.
