S
SissyCakes
SissyCakes: Two sisters crafting homemade-quality cakes for every celebration.
5
Bakery
$$
SissyCakes: Two sisters crafting homemade-quality cakes for every celebration.
Located at 102 Fairfax Ave B in Louisville, SissyCakes is a bakery beloved for handcrafted desserts and convenient online ordering with in-store pickup. Customers praise friendly, accommodating service for birthdays, holidays, and any celebration, plus gluten-free options. A locally loved, women-owned, two-sister family operation, SissyCakes delivers consistently delicious orange juice cake and more.
No photos available
Handcrafted cakes for birthdays, holidays, and special events, tailored to your preferences.
Our signature moist, citrus-flavored cake made with real, high-quality ingredients.
Delicious cakes and desserts available for those with dietary restrictions.
Convenient order placement through our website with in-store pickup.
A variety of baked goods perfect for parties, gatherings, and gifts.
Claim SissyCakes to update business info, respond to reviews, and access analytics.
Overall rating
Lucas Stuart
Sissy Cakes in Louisville is one of those rare local gems that instantly makes you a repeat customer after just one visit. From the moment you walk in, you can tell that everything is made with genuine care, passion, and attention to detail. This isn’t just a bakery—it’s a place where baking is clearly treated as an art, and it shows in every single item they create. The standout for me, without question, is the orange juice cake. Calling it “amazing” almost feels like an understatement. It’s unbelievably moist, perfectly balanced, and bursting with bright, fresh citrus flavor that tastes like it was made with real, high-quality ingredients (because it clearly was). The sweetness is spot-on—not too heavy, not too light—and the orange flavor isn’t artificial or overpowering. It’s refreshing, comforting, and indulgent all at the same time. Every bite feels intentional, like someone truly cared about getting it just right. What really sets Sissy Cakes apart is the consistency and craftsmanship. You can tell these desserts aren’t rushed or mass-produced. They have that homemade quality you hope for but rarely find, paired with the polish and reliability of a professional bakery. Whether you’re grabbing something for a special occasion, bringing dessert to share with friends or family, or just treating yourself, you feel confident knowing it’s going to be a hit. If you’re in Louisville and haven’t tried Sissy Cakes yet, you’re truly missing out. And if you do go, make sure the orange juice cake is at the top of your list. It’s unforgettable, and honestly worth the trip all on its own.
Henry Putney
This place is the best! I usually stop by Paul’s to pick up their cakes, and they sell out quick.. for good reason. My girlfriend’s family lives in South Carolina and they always ask me to bring them the legendary orange juice cake whenever I visit. Great people, amazing quality, and truly a Louisville staple.
Brett Logsdon
This is a warning: Once you start devouring these delicious and flavorful cakes, there is no going back! Sissy Cakes makes it extremely easy and convenient to order online and pick up in store. I always look forward to talking with their friendly staff. Sissy Cakes does a fantastic job accommodating their customers for any occasion: birthdays, holidays, and any celebration imaginable. I enjoy supporting local, family-operated businesses. Sissy Cakes is AWESOME! 😎
Carter Casaburo
SissyCakes is the best cake I’ve ever had in my life. I haven’t bought a cake from anywhere but SissyCakes in almost 5 years. Always a favorite at any holidays and parties
lilly nutt
An amazing local, women-owned family business run by two sisters. They’re friendly, extremely reliable, and always accommodating. They even offer gluten free options! They seriously go above and beyond for their customers. Their customer service is great, but their cakes are even better!!! Consistently delicious, beautifully made, and baked with care. I get a cake for every event I go to! Highly highly recommend!
