TO
Taste of NY pizza
Authentic New York-style pizza slices, hot and crispy, right in the heart of Nashville.
4.4(5 reviews)
restaurant
$$
Authentic New York-style pizza slices, hot and crispy, right in the heart of Nashville.
Taste of NY pizza brings the classic New York slice experience to Nashville, serving up hot, crispy, and generously topped pizzas by the slice or whole pie. Located at 530 Church St, this cozy spot is perfect for a quick bite, late-night craving, or a taste of authentic NY-style pizza with a friendly, personal touch. With a 4.7-star rating from hundreds of reviews, we pride ourselves on fresh ingredients, fast service, and a welcoming atmosphere that keeps customers coming back for more.
No photos available
Freshly baked NY-style pizza slices, heated to crispy perfection in our ovens, available in various toppings.
Customizable whole pizzas made to order with high-quality ingredients for dine-in or takeout.
Open late with hot, fresh slices available even during late hours, perfect for a post-Broadway snack.
Sweet treats like cannolis to complement your pizza meal.
Fast and friendly service with options for fresh pies if slices are out, ensuring minimal wait times.
One of the best pizza spots around! The slices are always hot and fresh, and the full pies are just as good. Great variety, quick service, and fair prices. This place never disappoints 🍕🔥
This is the epitome of what hole-in-the-wall means. Small little shop selling cold by-the-slices that they heat up to crispy goodness in their ovens. There is a sign declaring cash is king, and using cards incurs a 3% or 3.5% markup (can’t remember which). I tried to break a $100 bill, but the nice girl told me she didn’t have enough cash in the till to break it. Card it is. I selected one slice of a bacon, sausage, pepperoni. It was ready pretty quick and it was good, if not a bit too salty. There was a shaker of garlic salt nearby, but I didn’t see any Parmesan or peppers at hand. I only saw them as I was walking out the door in a little bin. I think it is pretty decent pizza, if not a little dear at $8 something for a slice. It was pretty good though and I have little regret.
Great stop for a late night slice of pizza away from the chaos of Broadway. They are constantly putting new pizzas in the oven even late at night. Crispy delicious and HOT! Fast service and cozy seating to stop in for a quick bite.
I stopped in on my way home after noticing the sign for $4 slices. Honestly, I didn’t have high expectations for great pizza down here in Tennessee while just visiting. When I walked in, they didn’t have any plain slices ready, but one of the gentlemen inside offered to make a fresh pie if I didn’t mind waiting 10 minutes. I agreed, grabbed some cannolis and a bottle of water, and before long my slices were ready. What really stood out was how the owner and staff remembered my name and went out of their way to make the experience feel personal and welcoming. The food itself was fantastic, two giant, fresh from the oven slices that far exceeded my expectations, especially at $4 each. I can highly recommend this spot.
Great little place in downtown Nashville. I ordered 2 slices of pepperoni pizza. They were out so they made a fresh pie. OMG, the pizza was piping hot, the crust was hella crunchy and loaded with pepperoni. Best NY style pizza I’ve had outside of NY. The pizza was so good that I had to return the next night bc I couldn’t resist; I had to have more! Highly recommend this place for those who like NY style pizza. 5-stars all day long!
Claim Taste of NY pizza to update business info, respond to reviews, and access analytics.
