The Sicilian Butcher

We had birthday reservations but the restaurant is sooo good that paid patrons did not want to leave their tables and the wait "pushed us" towards a bar seating. This was serendipitous because we had the best time chatting with Robert and Ethan (bartenders) and other patrons at the bar that we were not remotely disappointed! The meatball ferris wheel was amazing as was the pork rollatini and gnocchi (not "no cheese" .... now a staff joke). DO NOT HESITATE TO VISIT. DO NOT BE DISAPPOINTED TO SIT AT THE BAR, it turns out to be the best seating! Thank you ❤️

I came to this restaurant with my friend for lunch and woah, everything was really really good. Customer service was great, food was great. Definitely recommended the meatballs ferris wheel. It was pretty good and the pasta was amazing. I would definitely coming back

We had a great time at the Sicilian Butcher! We were greeted by a friendly hostess, seated quickly and enjoyed a wonderful meal. We started with the Meatball Ferris Wheel, which was fun and delicious! Our server was energetic, friendly and took great care of us. I had Nonna's Canneloni and my wife had the Grilled Ribeye. And although we were quite full we did partake of the best Tiramisu I have ever had. I highly recommend this place when you are looking for a nice Italian dinner!

So glad we chose to celebrate our wedding anniversary with the family here. From making reservation to placing order and service it was a memorable experience. Haillie was very attentive without being overbearing. She was very helpful and recommended good options. The giant board is highly recommended for group of 10 or more. Most of us enjoyed and finished what we ordered. Some were just huge portion (pork parmigianno). I felt the marinara sauce was a bit too much that you couldn't taste anything else. Other than, the price is commensurate. Love the personal touch...card for our anniversary. Thanks for the wonderful evening and experience.

Here’s a polished 3-star dine-in review based on what you shared: ⭐⭐⭐ 3-Star Review “Dined in for a Sunday lunch party. The charcuterie board was excellent and definitely the highlight of the meal. Unfortunately, the meatballs and pasta were just okay and lacked flavor. The service was great—attentive and friendly throughout our visit. However, I was expecting more of that warm Italian aroma, which was noticeably missing. Overall, it was a pleasant experience, but the food could use more seasoning and authenticity.” the dessert was excellent too!