TT
The Taste Of Tradition Bakery
The Taste Of Tradition Bakery: Classic flavors, real ingredients.
5
Bakery
$
The Taste Of Tradition Bakery: Classic flavors, real ingredients.
The Taste Of Tradition Bakery welcomes guests in New Haven, Indiana with homey breads, pies, cookies, and jams. Customers praise its welcoming atmosphere, enticing aroma, and pastries made with real ingredients and no food dyes. Favorites include cinnamon rolls, old-fashioned sugar cookies, and coconut cream pie. The bakery also offers specialty pies, Thursday orders with Saturday morning pickup, and can handle large orders with advance notice.
No photos available
Freshly baked daily, including cinnamon rolls, cookies, and a variety of breads using real, wholesome ingredients.
Handcrafted pies in flavors like blueberry, cherry, peach, and strawberry rhubarb, available in large and small sizes.
Accommodating large or advance orders for events, with specialty pies available for Thursday ordering and Saturday pickup.
House-made jellies and jams, such as jalapeño jelly, perfect for gifting or personal use.
Premium coffee beans sold by the bag, ideal for pairing with our baked goods.
Claim The Taste Of Tradition Bakery to update business info, respond to reviews, and access analytics.
Overall rating
Brad Imhoff
A very welcoming and wonderful place! The smell of the baked goods when arriving draws you in! I had placed a rather large order, plenty of time in advance, and they were able to accommodate. Great tasting pastries!
T Kuehnert
We have been coming here for a while now, never been disappointed, just ordered and picked up coconut cream pie. Best i have ever had. There breads, cinnamon roles, cookies are a excellent choice, if u are not into pie. We order specialty pies on Thursday and pic up on Saturday morning. Great for the weekend.
Danielle Potts
The only thing bad about The Taste of Tradition Bakery is that I live 6 hours away!! I was visiting Fort Wayne for the first time and I love to check out bakeries wherever I travel. The Taste of Tradition was highly recommended online, and I was able to make it my very last stop before I hit the road back to NY. It was hard enough to make a decision from all the items there, but I went with the classic cinnamon rolls and some of the old fashion sugar cookies. I brought my items home and stuck in the freezer and now less than a week later, my cinnamon rolls are gone because they have been the perfect morning breakfast. No shortcuts, flavorful and generous ingredients, and an obvious expertise gained from years of baking. Make the effort to get here if you are in the area!
Kim
There cinnamon rolls are amazing. Real ingredients no food dyes. The way food is suppose to be. Also purchased there sugar cookies and jalapeño jelly was awesome!!! First time visiting here , I will be back.
Jeremy Spray
Wonderful place to get home made bread,pies, jams, cookies. Lg and small pies: Blueberry, cherry, sugar creme, apple, peach, strawberry rhubarb, peacan. Molasses cookies, chocolate chip,sugar cookie, oatmeal cookie. Really friendly people. 09_7_2023 My girlfriend and I buy our whole coffee beans here all the time. Today I bought a small strawberry rhubarb pie, small blueberry pie, and some chocolate chip cookies. I also bought 2 bags of whole bean coffee I spent $45.00. 👍👍👍👍👍😁😁😁😁😁.
