WI
What's In Your Attic
What's In Your Attic: Nostalgic treasures and unique finds awaiting discovery.
4.8
Retail Store
$$
What's In Your Attic: Nostalgic treasures and unique finds awaiting discovery.
What's In Your Attic in Blasdell is a welcoming home goods store where shoppers discover nostalgic pop culture collectibles, crystals, jewelry, and other curious finds. Located at 3701 McKinley Pkwy Unit 702, the shop is praised for helpful, friendly staff (including Abe and Chaz) and a lively, treasure-filled atmosphere with great prices and frequent new discoveries.
No photos available
Browse a curated selection of pop culture memorabilia, vintage items, and nostalgic treasures from various eras.
Explore unique crystals, gemstones, and handpicked jewelry pieces for personal use or gifting.
Find DVDs, musical instruments like amps and guitars, and other entertainment-related goods.
Discover eclectic home decor, furniture, and decorative items to add character to any space.
Enjoy flexible pricing options with willingness to negotiate on buying and selling items.
Upcoming addition of fish and aquarium supplies, bringing back a classic mall experience.
Claim What's In Your Attic to update business info, respond to reviews, and access analytics.
Overall rating
Noelle
Love this shop. They have the coolest stuff which make great gifts. They're willing to negotiate on prices for buying and sell. The staff is extremely helpful. Definitely recommend.
Amy Olivieri
What's in your Attic? has always been an awesome store to lose yourself in! I've been finding treasures there for a decade (found them at Eastern Hills Mall and now at McKinley Mall). There's always something new to discover, a trip down memory lane with the nostalgic pop culture collectibles, and even cool crystals and jewelry. Abe and Chaz and the rest of the team are genuinely kind and helpful. Never had a bad experience here!
CHAZZ MINTER
Amazing Store! Great people, that go outta the way to help you!! Awesome finds, great prices, incredible atmosphere!! You have to do yourself a favor and check them out! They come Highly recommended!!! 💯 👌😉🙂👍
Carl Zarcone
Absolutely amazing store staff was helpful, friendly and fun to talk to. I try to stop in at least once a week and always find something to buy. Sometimes I go and just people watch because it’s such a great place to explore. If I could write a book about this store I can’t even describe how many pages it would be of just pure excitement and fun. I make a list every time I go and never have trouble not filling out my list and get this they’re now going to be selling fish. It’s going to be so awesome. Remember going into the stores in the mall and you could buy fish for your aquarium or tank at home While they’re bringing it back. The only thing the store is missing is an espresso machine.
Cyd Dickson
I'm only gonna give this place a 4 because they did have alot of things in there. It's very organized . I liked that they had Amps, guitars, lots of DVD's. Staff were nice to me although their glass case says other wise Now let's talk about this though.... A glass case Glorifying a political figure....
