27th Steak & Potato

Five O'Clock Steakhouse at 2416 W State St in Milwaukee captures a Wisconsin Supper Club vibe with a warm, welcoming dining room. Guests consistently praise top-notch food and service—from bartenders to wait staff—who remember regulars' drinks. Highlights include a favorite New York Strip with au jus and blue cheese with mushrooms, all served with attentive, friendly hospitality that brings guests back year after year.

Located at 6024 W Bluemound Rd in Milwaukee, The Milwaukee Steakhouse showcases a classic steakhouse menu and reliable, friendly service. Reviewers praise the exceptional food and attentive staff, with Cheese singled out for recommendations and timing, and Alex the bartender noted for his excellent service. Reservations are helpful, and guests enjoy dishes like onion soup, calamari, deviled eggs, mashed potatoes, and a juicy filet.

Carnevor | Milwaukee’s Premier Steakhouse delivers fine dining with expertly prepared steaks in a modern, dark setting. Reviews highlight outstanding service and personalized touches—from a warm greeting by manager Mark to attentive servers like Michael who remember favorite seats and offer thoughtful pairings. Signature dishes such as bone-in filet and crab legs showcase quality ingredients and presentation, complemented by well-crafted sides and drinks.

Eddie Martini's is a classic, old-school supper-club style steakhouse in Wauwatosa, Wisconsin. The polished, attentive service and upscale atmosphere earn frequent praise from guests. Signature dishes include dry-aged steaks, filet mignon, French onion soup with crunchy bread, escargot, seafood tower, lobster mac, and a rich chocolate cake dessert. A Milwaukee-area staple for those seeking a distinguished dining experience.

Rare Steakhouse offers fine-dining steak and seafood with a wine-bar experience in an intimate Milwaukee setting. Located at 833 E Michigan St, Milwaukee, WI 53202, it earns praise for chef-driven flavors and attentive, knowledgeable service in an elegant atmosphere. Highlights include warm sourdough bread and table-side banana foster, with a welcoming staff ensuring a memorable visit.

Mason Street Grill delivers a refined steakhouse experience in Milwaukee, with steaks cooked to perfection, standout apps and sides, and a notable wine list highlighted by Châteauneuf du Pape. Guests praise attentive, accommodating service and a welcoming ambiance, plus desserts like chocolate cake, carrot cake, and a mousse bomb. A trusted spot for locals and visitors alike.