The Milwaukee Steakhouse

Eddie Martini's is a classic, old-school supper-club style steakhouse in Wauwatosa, Wisconsin. The polished, attentive service and upscale atmosphere earn frequent praise from guests. Signature dishes include dry-aged steaks, filet mignon, French onion soup with crunchy bread, escargot, seafood tower, lobster mac, and a rich chocolate cake dessert. A Milwaukee-area staple for those seeking a distinguished dining experience.

Five O'Clock Steakhouse at 2416 W State St in Milwaukee captures a Wisconsin Supper Club vibe with a warm, welcoming dining room. Guests consistently praise top-notch food and service—from bartenders to wait staff—who remember regulars' drinks. Highlights include a favorite New York Strip with au jus and blue cheese with mushrooms, all served with attentive, friendly hospitality that brings guests back year after year.

27th Steak & Potato in Milwaukee offers a bold menu of steak, burgers, sandwiches, and American classics at 3158 S 27th St. Known for generous portions, favorites include rib eye with loaded potatoes, and fresh, well-seasoned dishes. Reviewers praise friendly staff, hot, tasty meals, and even Dubai chocolate cake as a must-try. Off-street parking and a clean, welcoming setting.

Carnevor | Milwaukee’s Premier Steakhouse delivers fine dining with expertly prepared steaks in a modern, dark setting. Reviews highlight outstanding service and personalized touches—from a warm greeting by manager Mark to attentive servers like Michael who remember favorite seats and offer thoughtful pairings. Signature dishes such as bone-in filet and crab legs showcase quality ingredients and presentation, complemented by well-crafted sides and drinks.

Mason Street Grill delivers a refined steakhouse experience in Milwaukee, with steaks cooked to perfection, standout apps and sides, and a notable wine list highlighted by Châteauneuf du Pape. Guests praise attentive, accommodating service and a welcoming ambiance, plus desserts like chocolate cake, carrot cake, and a mousse bomb. A trusted spot for locals and visitors alike.

Mo’s...A Place for Steaks in Milwaukee delivers upscale steakhouse dining with refined service and a polished ambiance. Notable reviews highlight a standout ribeye, bacon-wrapped scallops with garlic cream sauce, and attentive staff that anticipates guests' needs. The venue combines a bar with fine dining, and offers valet or street/garage parking. Ideal for celebrations and special occasions.