BP
Broadway Pizza
Broadway Pizza: topping-packed pies that keep Memphis coming back.
3.6
Pizza
$$
Broadway Pizza: topping-packed pies that keep Memphis coming back.
Broadway Pizza is a Memphis staple offering pizza and Italian-inspired dishes at 2581 Broad Ave. Customer reviews celebrate pizzas loaded with toppings, a meaty, cheesy crust, and items like BBQ shrimp, Around the World sausage, catfish, spaghetti, and fresh desserts. While some visits note long waits, the pies and flavors consistently win praise.
No photos available
Generously topped pizzas including 'Around the World' varieties, BBQ shrimp, and custom combinations, cut in squares for sharing.
Classic dishes like catfish and spaghetti, juicy burgers, fresh salads, and homestyle plate lunches (varies by location).
Fresh cakes, brownies, and sweet treats made daily to complement your meal.
Casual restaurant seating for families and groups, though note potential wait times during busy periods.
Convenient pickup service for enjoying our pizzas and meals at home or on the go.
Claim Broadway Pizza to update business info, respond to reviews, and access analytics.
Overall rating
Rick Wells
This location by far is my favorite. I have never had a pizza that was not up to standards. They never served me a burnt pie. It's a little further out than the Mendenhall location but I'm willing to sacrifice gas and time for a good pie.
Shawn Cash
The pizza is probably good when it's fresh? After almost 2 hours, I didn't actually get to try it. Appetizers took over 45 minutes and were cold. First and probably last time there. Definitely would not recommend.
Anna Trollinger
First time visiting this specific location of Broadway Pizza - only ever been to the one on Mendenhall in the past. The person accompanying me had never eaten at any Broadway locations. Was not disappointed with our visit, but also not highly satisfied. Had a table for 2 during lunch and there was no lunch rush, in fact the restaurant wasn’t packed at all. We seated ourselves and it was a while before we were ever waited on. Once our drink order was taken, we waited another 20-30 minutes before receiving them (non alcoholic beverages). We ordered the “around the world sausage” pizza (as pictured) but was not expecting the hour long wait to receive it. Would not recommend coming by here on your lunch break seeing as our visit exceeded 2 hours and there was no lunch rush. We also noticed ours and nearby table’s pizzas not served with a serving spatula, which made it difficult to plate the pizza while it was hot, and tricky to pack up leftovers (it came cut in squares rather than slices, so it can be messy picking up pieces). We enjoyed the pizza itself! Definitely loaded with toppings and they don’t skimp out on them. Overall, the pizza was great and we liked it! Although the food was tasty, we were dissatisfied with the service we received and the turnaround time of the drinks and pizza.
Tim Skinner
The pizza is really good. Very meaty and cheesy. The booths are tight so we sat at a table. Takes a minute to get your order in and to the table. I was also going to get a plate lunch to go but this location doesn’t do plate lunches even though it’s on the menu. You’d have to go to the other location. I still love the pizza here.
CamilleRekia
I love Broadway! Pizza is always good with plenty of toppings. It's always cooked perfectly and holds together well. I usually get 1/2 bbq shrimp and 1/2 beef around the world. This is my favorite combination. The bbq shrimp is a must-have if you like shrimp and the bbq meat on it is really good too. There cakes and brownies are definitely good and always fresh😋 I also like the catfish and spaghetti dinner, the burgers are big and juicy, and the salads are good too. I have been going to both locations for years and have never had a complaint, ever. There will be a 30-plus minute wait, but it is worth it.
