Classic Slice

Transfer Pizzeria Café at 101 W Mitchell St in Milwaukee blends a preserved Pharmacy interior - with counter, stools, and original tile - with bold, crave-worthy pizzas. Guests rave about the atmosphere, friendly service (Gina among the attentive staff), and gluten-free options with strong cross-contamination precautions. Specialty pies like pickle pizza and the Dill, plus reliable delivery, round out the vibrant dining experience.

Fixture Pizza Pub in Milwaukee offers a welcoming dining experience with ample seating, a bar, booths, and outdoor options. Diners praise bold, topping-rich pies, including a standout deep-dish and the tattoo pizza, plus flavorful garlic bread, mozzarella sticks, and pesto pasta. Guests note friendly, attentive service and a cozy, dimly lit vibe.

Zaffiro's Pizza The Original in Milwaukee serves ultra-thin, crispy tavern-style pies with generously distributed toppings and a subtly sweet sauce. The vintage dining room—red checkered tablecloths and old-school charm—paired with attentive staff creates a cozy, welcoming tavern-style spot that guests repeatedly praise.

Pizza Shuttle on 1827 N Farwell Ave is an iconic Milwaukee staple offering NY-style, bready and cheesy slices alongside hearty comfort fare. Open late with reliable delivery, it's a family-friendly spot that shines after nights out. Reviews praise budget-friendly options, tasty cheese sticks, and a bold, garish interior that keeps the East Side buzzing.

Maggio's Wood Fired Pizza in Wauwatosa offers stone-oven pizzas with crispy, light crusts and fresh ingredients at 7212 W North Ave, Wauwatosa, WI 53213, USA. Reviewers describe perfect crusts, balanced flavors, and non-greasy toppings, with favorites like Margherita and pesto Margherita, plus garlic bread and honey butter bites. The warm atmosphere and friendly staff comfortably serve groups.