Dine-in experience with creative thin-crust pizzas in a historic, art-filled atmosphere.
Dedicated gluten-free pizzas prepared in a separate oven for celiac-safe dining.
Reliable pizza delivery to your home or office with consistent quality.
Selection of local craft beers and café beverages to complement your meal.
Private events and gatherings in our unique historic venue space.
Unique pizza creations like The Dill with pickles or garlic base with spinach and feta.
I've been waiting to write this review as I like to try a place a few times for consistency and to make sure I don't get sick. I have celiac and am super sensitive to cross contamination. I have eaten their GF pizza four times now without incident. It's delicious (especially the Billy Bob) and they take GF seriously,(separate oven, etc.). My family can have gluten and they love the regular pizzas too. Wonderful place, especially for those with celiac.
We get delivery pizza from here with some frequency. Have to say 11/11/25 whoever has been on crust duty recently nailed it. 🤌🏻 This, to me isn’t the place for your basic pepperoni/ sausage, etc. I mean they’re fine, but I really like their specialty pizzas. Over the years it’s been consistently good, and delivery service great. And the times we’ve dined in have always been nice. It’s a unique and vibrant space.
We loved the food, service, and atmosphere! Visiting from out of town and stopped in for lunch. I ordered a garlic pizza plus green olives with gluten free crust. Best pizza ever, thin crust, amazing flavors, and excellent gluten free food safety precautions. Thank you!
The place is cool, it is in an old Pharmacy " Transfer Pharmacy" and they left the counter and stools in place as well as some of the original tile floor. It is worth going to see just this, but the pizza was very good. Kind of a cracker crust, but tasty. Service was great, Gina was our server and she was on it, personable joking around with us, it made the visit all that much better. Very accommodating as well. I will be back, you should check it out!
Family took me here and said it was awesome pizza and they were right!! Everything from the atmosphere, staff, and food were amazing. We ordered two large pizzas and the spinach artichoke dip to share amongst 4 people. Plenty of leftovers!! We ordered The Dill (PERFECTION!!!). My first time trying a pickle pizza and they nailed it. It was delicious. We also ordered a garlic base with spinach and feta. That was enjoyed very much! Dip was also yummy and comes with bread. Love the artwork throughout the restaurant!

Historic pharmacy turned pizza paradise with craft brews and gluten-free options in Milwaukee.
No photos available
Transfer Pizzeria Café offers a unique dining experience in a beautifully preserved historic pharmacy building on Mitchell Street. We specialize in artisanal thin-crust pizzas with creative toppings, alongside a curated selection of craft beers and café beverages. Our commitment to food safety, especially for gluten-free diners with separate ovens, ensures everyone can enjoy our delicious offerings. Whether you're dining in our vibrant, art-filled space, ordering delivery, or hosting an event, we provide exceptional service and memorable flavors that keep our community coming back.
Claim Transfer Pizzeria Café to update business info, respond to reviews, and access analytics.