Common Pasta

Located at 2903 University Ave in Madison, Osteria Novella offers inviting Italian dining in a compact, efficient space. Reviews highlight superb food, attentive service, and a welcoming atmosphere, with antipasti, pizzas, and pastas such as cavatelli and pappardelle ai porcini, plus desserts like cannoli and zeppole. Reservations are recommended for weekend dining, with on-street parking nearby.

Salvatore's Tomato Pies - Madison serves Italian-style pizzas in 10" and 16" sizes, with gluten-free crusts available. The menu pairs rotating seasonal flavors with staples, and features a full bar with cocktails. Guests praise attentive, friendly service, a cozy neon-lit atmosphere, and easy parking in the adjacent garage. The venue is popular for groups and Wednesday trivia nights.

Osteria Papavero offers fresh Italian cuisine in Madison with a daily rotating menu. Guests praise the fresh pasta—Cinghiale pasta and al dente pappardelle—and dishes like sea trout, plus game meats such as wild boar, antelope, and camel. Desserts include Budino di Caramello, ricotta cake, and crostata; negronis are also highlighted. Reservations are advised as it stays lively.

Cento is a Madison, Wisconsin Italian restaurant offering elevated, classy dining with quality pasta, seasonal small plates, and thoughtful cocktails. Highlights include creste di gallo with tomatoes, spinach, and spicy sausage, a standout butcher board, and attentive, knowledgeable service. Gluten-free pasta and pizza are available; reservations are recommended on busy nights. Some guests note the open layout can be loud.

Fabiola's Spaghetti House & Deli welcomes guests to a comfortable, intimate Italian dining experience in Madison. Patrons note attentive, friendly service and flavorful dishes like fettuccine, eggplant parm, and linguine vongole. The bar offers a solid wine list and the desserts—gelato and tiramisu—are a highlight, making it a well-loved addition to Madison's Italian scene.

Lucille is a downtown Madison pizza restaurant located at 101 King St. Customer reviews praise its bold pizzas, including vegetarian and gluten-free options, and a standout cheese pull. The lively retro décor and attentive staff create a welcoming atmosphere for meals or drinks, even during busy hours.