Osteria Novella

Nonno's Ristorante Italiano in Madison (704 S Whitney Way) serves authentic Italian dishes and pizzas with a welcoming, unhurried service. Reviews praise fresh starters like oysters, homemade pastas, lasagna, gnocchi, and desserts, with generous portions and thoughtful staff recommendations. Guests note bright atmosphere, affordable prices for high-end flavors, and options for dine-in or take-home portions.

Lombardino's Restaurant in Madison offers real Italian cuisine in a warm, inviting setting. Diners praise delicious pizzas and pastas, with standout dishes like beef short rib, polenta, tagliatelle with truffled mushroom, and tiramisu. Expect waits on busy evenings, but bar seating and being called when a table is ready ease the experience. Local ingredients and friendly service contribute to a memorable dining night.

Luigi's Pizza in Madison, WI, serves Italian favorites with a homemade flavor. Customers praise pizza and pasta delivered hot and well packed, with pasta portions comparable to dining in. Favorites include spaghetti and meatballs, dough knots, and The Goods white sauce pizza. Friendly service and accommodating groups round out a welcoming dining and delivery experience.

Fabiola's Spaghetti House & Deli welcomes guests to a comfortable, intimate Italian dining experience in Madison. Patrons note attentive, friendly service and flavorful dishes like fettuccine, eggplant parm, and linguine vongole. The bar offers a solid wine list and the desserts—gelato and tiramisu—are a highlight, making it a well-loved addition to Madison's Italian scene.

Cento is a Madison, Wisconsin Italian restaurant offering elevated, classy dining with quality pasta, seasonal small plates, and thoughtful cocktails. Highlights include creste di gallo with tomatoes, spinach, and spicy sausage, a standout butcher board, and attentive, knowledgeable service. Gluten-free pasta and pizza are available; reservations are recommended on busy nights. Some guests note the open layout can be loud.

Eat the Best Pizza is a Madison pizza restaurant at 711 State Street. Diners praise crispy crusts, flavorful pies, and the option to grab a slice, with favorites like margarita and supreme. Reviewers also note friendly, attentive staff and a welcoming owner. The menu features buffalo chicken and BBQ chicken pizzas, garlic knots, and baklava, with late hours noted by customers.