Gambill's Pastaria | Fresh Pasta & Sourdough Pizza

Pie Hole Pizzeria sits at 2708 E 15th St, Tulsa, offering customizable slices with a woodfire-esque crust. Reviews praise bold flavors, roasted garlic, and friendly, quick service, plus vegan options like cauliflower crust with vegan cheese. The cozy lobby features a pinball table and local flyers, and there is no indoor seating. Slices are affordable and highly customizable.

Andolini's Pizzeria Cherry Street in Tulsa's Cherry Street district serves pizza with a fabulous crust and delicious toppings, along with pasta options and other favorites mentioned by guests. Reviewers praise a cozy, clean atmosphere and welcoming, attentive service, with staff highlighted by names like Casey and Bryce. Located minutes from the Expo Center, it’s a reliable spot for dine-in or takeout during events.

Prossimo Ristorante in Tulsa offers an elegant, high-end dining experience where artful Italian cuisine meets attentive service. Guests praise generous portions, refined flavor balance, and dishes like table-side cheese wheel prep, chicken parm, shrimp cakes, and Alfredo. The atmosphere blends white-tablecloth polish with unpretentious warmth, and servers such as Allen, Becky, and Grayson guide guests through flavorful journeys with thoughtful pairings.

Hideaway Pizza is a Tulsa pizza restaurant offering Italian-inspired pies and classic dishes. Customers praise fast, friendly service and flavorful pizzas such as Porkpalooza, Pizza of the Gods, Maui Magic, and Big Country, plus salads like a customizable Cobb Salad with grilled chicken. Takeout is reliably ready on time, and the venue carries a warm, boho-chic vibe.

sapori is a Tulsa Italian restaurant at 1344 E 15th St, Tulsa, OK 74120. Diners praise Italian favorites from pizza and bruschetta to saffron risotto with scallops and chicken piccata, plus tiramisu, with noted wine pairings. The refreshed dining area and high-energy, attentive staff enhance the welcoming vibe. An outdoor patio with heaters and fans adds year-round comfort.

Malfi Enoteca in Tulsa offers authentic Italian dining with fan-favorite dishes like white bean dip with rosemary and pancetta, bruschetta, bucatini with basil cream and pesto, plus herb-roasted chicken and roasted salmon. The menu's newspaper-style format and bar seating set a warm tone, with standout service from Alexis and Jose. Reservations are recommended for popular dining.