GP
Goodfellas Pizzeria - OTR
Goodfellas Pizzeria - OTR: Late-night pizza, friendly service, and a speakeasy-style bar.
4.6
Pizza
$
Goodfellas Pizzeria - OTR: Late-night pizza, friendly service, and a speakeasy-style bar.
Goodfellas Pizzeria - OTR serves Cincinnati with late-night pizza and dine-in or to-go options. Reviews praise professional, friendly staff and a well-prepared pie with flavorful sauce and good dough texture. The venue features a speakeasy-style bar upstairs with a broad whiskey/bourbon selection, and Monday promotions have impressed guests.
No photos available
Large, freshly made pizza slices with a variety of toppings, available late into the night.
A unique bar area with an extensive selection of whiskeys, bourbons, and other drinks in a cool, historic atmosphere.
Flexible service with seating available for eating in or convenient takeout for on-the-go meals.
Pizza options catering to vegetarians and customizable orders with fresh ingredients.
Housemade breadsticks and other sides like nacho cheese to complement your meal.
Claim Goodfellas Pizzeria - OTR to update business info, respond to reviews, and access analytics.
Overall rating
Moe Habib
Everything was great, the staff were professional and friendly. I ordered two pizza one cheese and the other with few Veggies and Beef. The sauce was good, the dough had good texture, perfectly cooked but was tough. It gives your jaws a good workout. I am assuming the dough was fresh and didn’t have time to rest. Another complaint I have, I ordered beef for my pizza topping and without exaggeration, you can’t see it, it felt like beef powder. I paid 80+ and didn’t enjoy to be honest. However, I understand it was late night so I am going to try them again and write a fair review: UPDATE: 12/27/25 We came in again, but during the day to try it out again. Different staff, still professional and very friendly. They took our order which was almost exactly the same as last time but this time i came with guests. Now thats a ***** great pizza. The dough was perfect the sauce was amazing and the portions for the beef was just perfect. 12/29/25 I am now here again with the kids. We were greeted by Dunk’n, he was great, remembered us immediately, gave us a vip treatment, helped us with Monday promotions, without even knowing about the review. His attitude and hospitality made our day. Will definitely make this our future go to place.
Cat
Excellent pizza and drink selections!! Helpful and gracious staff. We didn't know what we were doing; crazy tourists!!!
Emily
Love the fact the pizza is available pretty late. We bought a couple of slices. They are pretty good sized! Not bad pizza. The atmosphere is nice too. The bar upstairs has a ton of whiskey or bourbon. If you like that stuff its definitely the place to get top shelf booze.
Emily Anderson
Really well prepared pizza. Vegetarian options. All the other pizzas looked good too. Large slices. We went a little after 900p and they still had a lot to pick from. Huge bread sticks. Nice spot with the bar upstairs. We got our pizza to go. You have the option to eat in as well.
Paul Johnson
Pizza was tasty like always. Breadstick could have been a little sifter but was good especially when paired with nacho cheese. Lots of seating options in the speakeasy with a cool bar! Staff is friendly and helpful. Worth a stop!
