Services Offered
New York-Style Pizza
Large slices and whole pies with a variety of toppings, available for dine-in, takeout, or delivery.
Upstairs Bar & Lounge
A full-service bar offering bourbon, cocktails, craft beers, and a rooftop area for socializing.
Breadsticks and Appetizers
Soft, huge breadsticks and other Italian starters to complement your meal.
Catering and Large Orders
Perfect for parties and events, with options for bulk pizza and group dining.
Special Offers and Events
Weekly deals like Monday discounts and themed events like pizza week with unique creations.
Reviews
4.2(5 reviews)
Rating Distribution
5
4
4
0
3
0
2
0
1
1
M
Malinda Page
via Google
about 2 months ago
We heard about this spot while researching for out vacation on YouTube. It did not disappoint! The breadsticks are so soft and they are huge! Pizza was great. We spent under $40 for the food. We went upstairs where they delivered our pizza to our table and we bought drinks at the bar. So many kinds of bourbon to choose from! Not sure what we spent on drinks. The guys each had two bourbon cocktails and the ladies each had one fruity cocktail. If we find ourselves in the area again we will definitely be back!
A
Adit Doshivia Google
3 months ago
DO NOT FALL FOR THIS TRAP - MONDAY 50% OFF. I ordered pizzas on Monday online. The pizzas were too much bread, little toppings and very less cheese. See the pictures. The borders were completely empty. Usually, their slices are good. But they cut corners on 50% off pizzas. I would have been better off ordering dominos or pizza hut. Disappointed. @goodfellas pizzeria - if it does not work for you financially, do not give the offer but please do not feed crap.
M
MEGHAN CUMAvia Google
3 months ago
Great large pizza slice for a fair price and a fun upstairs bar as well! We came this past weekend and it was decked out on holiday decour. If you do go to the upstairs bar try their peanut butter shot!
C
Crystal Binfordvia Google
3 months ago
Great first impression. Went for pizza week. The Moe "Truffle" Greene pizza is DELICIOUS! Waited in the upstairs bar and had a strawberry cider. If you are not a beer drinker, this is for you.
A
Alek Elovia Google
8 months ago
It has been a week now being in Cincinnati, after searching the web looking for dinner spots I came across this place, came in looking for a pizza and left with a changed perspective on the pizza and service industry. Everybody part of the staff was super easy going and made the experience smooth, especially Chris at the front hooked me and my buddy up with some great eats and even got us top floor access to the rooftop. Definitely will be coming back, from his hospitality to the food, this place is doing it right!
