Goodfellas Pizzeria - Pleasant Ridge

Located at 3392 Erie Ave in Cincinnati, Saint Francis Apizza - Hyde Park (Take Out Only Pizza) specializes in takeout pizza. Reviews praise a standout crust—French bread–style sourdough with a pleasant char—along with fresh sauce and solid cheese. Some pies reach 16 inches with multiple toppings, reflecting favorable value for local takeout.

Fireside Pizza blends a historic firehouse setting with wood-fired pizzas and a lively bar. Located at 773 E McMillan St in Cincinnati, it earns praise for light, airy crusts and flavorful toppings, including standout chicken pizzas. The venue also offers fresh cocktails, including seasonal varieties, and a warm, friendly service that guests describe as welcoming and memorable.

Cork N Crust is a family-owned pizza restaurant and wine bar in Bellevue, KY. Located at 710 Fairfield Ave, it serves a generous menu of pizzas and a crowd-pleasing wine selection (including flights) with noted 16 wine taps. Guests praise friendly service, a warm rustic vibe, and dishes like toasted ravioli and garlic dip.

Adriatico's is a Cincinnati pizza restaurant known for thick, doughy crusts and plenty of toppings. Guests rave about spicy, gooey cheese and calzones with garlic butter. The casual, college-vibe spot also offers salads, takeout, and delivery. Some reviews mention parking challenges and occasional service hiccups, but the pizzas win frequent praise.

Goodfellas Pizzeria - OTR serves Cincinnati with late-night pizza and dine-in or to-go options. Reviews praise professional, friendly staff and a well-prepared pie with flavorful sauce and good dough texture. The venue features a speakeasy-style bar upstairs with a broad whiskey/bourbon selection, and Monday promotions have impressed guests.

Two Cities Pizza Co. in Mason, OH serves a hybrid menu of New York–style and Chicago deep-dish pizza, including half-and-half pies and a cauliflower crust option. Reviews praise friendly staff, a welcoming atmosphere, and outdoor seating. Guests also note house-made ranch, and a NYC subway–themed bathroom that adds a playful touch to the visit.