La Pizza Italia

Quality Pizza Co. Midtown is a New York pizza spot located at 888 6th Ave. It offers single slices and whole pizzas, with counter service and indoor seating for dining in. Pizzas are often reheated in the oven to restore warmth and crispiness, and toppings such as garlic, oregano and parmesan are available at the counter. Reviews praise affordable pricing and tasty slices, with overall experiences varying by slice.

Joe's Pizza Broadway is a lively New York staple offering hot, crispy slices with a simple, classic menu. Patrons praise affordable prices, fresh slices heated at the counter, and quick, efficient service despite lines. With a loud, busy atmosphere and limited seating, it’s a dependable stop after a Broadway night or a busy day in the city.

Nuovo York Pizza serves classic New York–style pizza with crisp crust and generous fillings. Located at 105 E 9th St in the East Village, it’s known for a clean, welcoming space and friendly staff. Customers praise large, hot slices and inventive options like burrsta with arugula, pesto pepperoni, and Sicilian slices, plus parm extras and garlic knots.

East Village Pizza offers classic New York-style pies at 145 1st Ave. Customers rave about late-night slices, pepperoni that's 100% beef with jalapeños, and the double-stack pies. Known for thin crust, big slices with fresh toppings, and quick, friendly service even in busy moments, it delivers a true NYC slice experience.

PizzaStudio is located in the food court at Newport Center Mall, 30 Mall Dr W, Jersey City. It offers pizzas including gluten-free crust and a 'choose your own' option with fresh toppings. Reviewers praise a crispy crust, generous toppings, and notable pies like Masala Street Corn and a vegan personal pizza. Toppings and spices, such as garlic powder and red pepper flakes, are available, and the staff are described as warm and welcoming.

Bleecker Street Pizza serves classic New York style pies at 69 7th Ave S, New York. Reviews praise the thin, crispy crust and a well-balanced trio of sauce, cheese, and seasoning, calling it among the best NYC pizza. The pies are flavorful and well-cooked, with a relaxed ambience that suits dine-in, takeout, or delivery.