Quality Pizza Co. Midtown

Name: Quality Pizza Co. Midtown
Address: 888 6th Avenue, New York, NY, 10001, US
Telephone: (646) 858-0048
Price range: $
Rating: 3.8

Authentic New York slices, hot and crispy, served with a smile.

3.8(5 reviews)

pizza

fast-food

Claim this business

Services Offered

Single Pizza Slices

Choose from a variety of fresh slices, heated to order for a crispy, warm experience.

Whole Pizzas

Order full pies for groups or takeout, available with classic and specialty toppings.

Dine-In Seating

Comfortable indoor seating area for enjoying your pizza on-site in a casual setting.

Counter Service

Friendly and efficient service at the counter with quick ordering and payment options.

Toppings Bar

Self-serve station with garlic, oregano, and parmesan to customize your slice to taste.

Reviews

3.8(5 reviews)

Rating Distribution

Heiko Gehrig

via Google

about 2 months ago

Got the BBQ pizza. Was decent. Italian style thing crust. Tasty. The one staff I interacted with seemed impartial. Ask for my order, and heated my slice. No thank you or smile, but I guess I’m here for the pizza, thanks to the reviews.

Mar Pepin

via Google

2 months ago

We were staying at a hotel near Penn Station/MSG and I really wanted a New York slice. We looked at some of the other options but a lot of them either were more expensive or did not look good, so we ended up choosing this place. We walked in and ordered at the counter, then got a table to eat at. I got two slices of pepperoni pizza, and my sister got two slices of cheese pizza and a water bottle for $7. They had garlic, oregano, parmesan available on the counter. The person working was very nice and wiped down tables in between orders. The pizza was warmed in the oven and tasted amazing. I was very happy with the price and the taste of the pizza!

Emily Wall

via Google

3 months ago

I got a slice of cheese pizza. It cost $3.81. It's served nice and hot. The crust is thin and crispy. There's not quite enough cheese for my taste. There is some indoor seating which is always nice to have. It's fine, but not something I would go out of my way to get.

Clay Patrick (ClayDay)

via Google

3 months ago

They had a large selection of pizza to choose from as single slices and the option to get a whole pizza. I got a slice of the chicken bacon ranch and buffalo chicken pizza. I thought they were super tasty! They throw them back in to the oven to heat back up from the display. It makes them just the right amount of crispy and warm.

King Monty

via Google

6 months ago

I was really unhappy with the quality of pizza here. This was our first stop due to high ratings and distance. We ordered a slice each, and were very disappointed with the texture and taste. The bread/ crust of the pizza was dry like cardboard, and although the pizza looked savory and had great color pop from the mix of toppings, it was devoid of flavor and lacked substance. It tasted like it has been out for far too long. Although the location was convenient, the overall experience was not pleasant. This was our first attempt at finding great New York style pizza, and it left us disappointed.