Lady Monarch

Located at 689 N High St, Columbus, Alexanders Jewelers earns strong praise for professional, attentive service and a curator's selection of watches and engagement rings. Reviews cite non-pressure guidance, quick special orders for brands like Rolex, Cartier, and Tissot, precise sizing and enhancements, and timegrapher checks that illustrate quality and accuracy. A trusted destination for milestone jewelry purchases.

Diamond Cellar in Columbus is praised for professional, personalized jewelry shopping, from resizing rings to selecting engagement rings and notable watches such as Rolex. Reviewers at both Columbus locations describe a welcoming team—Dawn, Jeff, Jim, Mary—who guide customers with care, transparent processes, and helpful tools like 3D online models and wax replicas. The result is a first-class, memorable experience.

Krysty Designs in Columbus offers custom jewelry design, on-site modifications, and redesigns of existing pieces. Led by Brad Krysty and a friendly team, the store guides customers through a collaborative process with warm, attentive service and meticulous craftsmanship. Clients celebrate memory-filled creations, on-site stud adjustments, and store credit for old pieces, all culminating in one-of-a-kind jewelry that feels personal.

Diamonds Direct Columbus at 1330 Polaris Pkwy is a jewelry store known for engagement rings and repairs. Reviews highlight attentive, knowledgeable staff like Ryan Choops, Marci Gold, Lorenzo, Enrique Cervantes, and Kevin, who offer friendly, no-pressure guidance and quick, careful repairs. Customers praise exquisite ring selection and personalized service that helps them find the perfect pieces.

Carioti Jewelers, located at 175 Cleveland Ave in Columbus, is a family-owned jewelry store famed for personalized, transparent service. Customers praise welcoming, patient staff, honest guidance, and expert craftsmanship in custom engagement rings and timepieces, plus reliable repairs and flexible financing options.

Located at 861 N High St in Columbus, Koulian Jewelers is a trusted jewelry store known for in-house craftsmanship, custom ring settings, and care for heirloom pieces. Customer reviews highlight warm, knowledgeable staff, thoughtful design, and a pressure-free shopping experience. Services include ring resizing, quick in-house work, and a clean, organized showroom with a wide selection.