Services Offered
Artisanal Sourdough Pizzas
Hand-tossed 12" pizzas with creative toppings like cupped pepperoni, mushroom, and potato leek, featuring our signature sourdough crust.
Curated Drink Selection
Enjoy wines, cocktails, and local beers at our bar, with happy hour specials available for dine-in customers.
Fresh Salads & Appetizers
Indulge in our popular Caesar salads (half or full size) and savory meatballs, made with high-quality ingredients.
Dine-In Experience
Cozy, TV-free atmosphere with friendly service, perfect for relaxed meals in our intimate seating area.
Carry-Out & Takeout
Convenient takeout options for enjoying our pizzas at home, with a small fee applied to carry-out orders.
Reviews
4.8(5 reviews)
Rating Distribution
5
4
4
1
3
0
2
0
1
0
H
Henry Karpf
via Google
about 2 months ago
Went here to grab a quick bite for dinner. Sat at the bar and had a caesar salad and pepperoni pizza. The pizza had delicious cupped pepperonis, and they were plentiful! The half caesar was well dressed and was huge, even at just the half size. A little on the pricey side, but a good treat every once in a while for a delicious pizza. Great drink selection and great server.
C
Chasity Walkvia Google
3 months ago
It was so good we couldn't wait to dig in before taking a picture. From the service, salad, and pizza everything was SO good.
H
Howard Lylevia Google
4 months ago
This is a mixed review. Lyle's Pizzeria uses a sourdough crust. My family and I didn't care for the taste of the crust but that is personal preference. You may like it. We ordered the supreme and the mushroom (x2) pizzas and the chopped salad. The toppings were generous and the cheese blends were tasty. The crust was hand tossed and the chew on the crust had a great mouth feel. The pizzas only came in one size - 12". The restaurant is small but that gave it a cozy feel. There was not any background music or TVs blaring, that I recall, which would make a pleasant dine-in experience. We did order carry-out for which they added an additional 10% fee on the total order and the happy hour special prices apply to dine-in only. Both were nominal, in either case, so not a show stopper. Overall, I would recommend the pizza. We are willing to try it again, the potato and leek pizza sounds intriguing, now that we know what to expect from the taste of the crust.
D
Deborah Petersvia Google
5 months ago
My sister and I stopped by on a whim. We are from Texas. The atmosphere is nice and the staff were very kind and polite. We ordered a pizza and 2 Cesar Salads. The salad was the best Cezar salad I’ve ever eaten. We each ordered the half size and it was a more than an ample serving. Loved the crust on the pizza. If we lived here Lyle’s would be our go to pizza place.
J
Jeremy Nevillevia Google
7 months ago
Pizza is amazing!!!! Started off the evening with a Cesar salad and meatballs. Than finished the evening with three pizzas and a few cocktails. Everything on the menu is good and worth a try.
