PP
Pitch Pizzeria
Pitch Pizzeria: Bold pizza, fine wines, memorable gatherings.
4.4
Pizza
$$
Pitch Pizzeria: Bold pizza, fine wines, memorable gatherings.
Pitch Pizzeria is a pizza restaurant and wine bar in Omaha, at 5021 Underwood Ave, offering Italian-inspired pies and a welcoming dining scene. Guests praise phenomenal pizzas—such as goat cheese peppedew peppers and the Proteina pizza—alongside a strong wine list. The venue handles gatherings well, with attentive service and a space that feels private for groups, even without a dedicated party room. Gluten-free slices are available, and the You Pick 2 option provides solid value.
No photos available
Handcrafted pizzas with creative toppings, including gluten-free options, available for dine-in or takeout.
Curated wines, beers, and cocktails served in a relaxed bar setting, perfect for pairing with meals.
Customized rehearsal dinners, parties, and group gatherings with excellent planning and service for up to 40 guests.
Full-service meals featuring deals like 'You Pick 2!' with pizza, salads, and appetizers in a vibrant atmosphere.
Convenient options to enjoy our pizzas and sides at home, with online ordering available.
Claim Pitch Pizzeria to update business info, respond to reviews, and access analytics.
Overall rating
Sue Ellen Hall
We hosted a rehearsal dinner here the day after Christmas. What a fantastic event from start to finish! Great prior planning and execution of our party for 40 people. Even without a designated party space, we had the entire back half of the restaurant to ourselves and it felt very private. The tables were lovely, the service was excellent and the food and wine were simply outstanding!! Many many thanks to Dean and his excellent team!
Alan Fitzpatrick
Phenomenal pizza! We ordered the goat cheese peppedew peppers to share and split the Proteina pizza! Amazing flavor combos and generously topped pizza! Can't wait to go back!
Natalia Gonzalez
Bittersweet experience! The manager/host (a young gentleman) came off very serious and a bit dry, but Elle completely turned things around with her warmth and energy. I’ve only ever come here for dinner before, not lunch, but the food is always incredible. Tip: If your first interaction feels a little stiff, don’t let it scare you off — it’s definitely worth staying. Thank you Elle for being a ray of sunshine ☺️
Katelin Tiernan
Gluten free pizza by the slice 🤯 and it was great! The crust struggles a little to hold up to the toppings, but I'm not gonna complain because they were amazing and I'd rather have too much than too little for sure. My boyfriend enjoyed his normal crust slice as well. Overall a good deal given the size of the slices!
Wendy Webb
I liked the vibe of this restaurant but the high-top table chairs were super uncomfortable. The service was good. Our food was just okay. The "You Pick 2!" is a pretty good deal. I got a slice of pizza and the meatballs. I had the Proteina and my husband got a slice of the Tin Man. My daughter got the Tai Salad but thought it was pretty flavorless. We also got the Piaso Cheese Bread.
