Mitchell's Steakhouse: where fine dining meets perfectly cooked steak and attentive service.
Mitchell's Steakhouse offers a downtown Columbus fine-dining experience with steak, seafood, and takeout options. Reviews highlight superb dishes like salmon and toasted chicken, mac and cheese, and mashed potatoes, along with attentive service in a beautiful setting. The downtown location and polished atmosphere attract repeat visitors, though some guests note variability in portions and value.
45 N 3rd St, Columbus, OH 43215, USA
Claim Mitchell's Steakhouse to manage your storefront, respond to reviews, and receive customer leads.
Hand-cut, aged steaks cooked to perfection, including filet mignon, ribeye, and New York strip.
High-quality seafood options like lobster, salmon, and shrimp cocktail, sourced for freshness.
Elegant ambiance with white-tablecloth service, ideal for special events and romantic dinners.
Customized menus and private dining spaces for groups, celebrations, and corporate functions.
Gourmet meals available for pickup, allowing you to enjoy our cuisine at home.
Expertly curated wine list and signature cocktails to enhance your dining experience.
Overall rating
Kimberly Jones
We had such a great time at Mitchell’s Steakhouse downtown. The food was amazing and cooked perfectly, and the restaurant itself is really beautiful. The downtown location is also super convenient and adds to the vibe. Our server, Nicole, was great—gave great recommendations, was very attentive, and made sure we had everything we needed. Overall a great experience and definitely a place I’d visit again!
Desiree Shull
I never leave reviews but I took my husband here for his birthday and it’s the most disappointed he’s ever been. It takes a lot for us to complain because we’ve both worked in the service industry and understand what it’s like. It took 20 minutes to get greeted and get our water. Our server brought the bread out and it had a long hair on it. He got a Caesar salad that tasted genuinely like dirt. His steak was supposed to be medium and it came out rare so he sent it back and when they brought him a new one it was still rare. We enjoyed the mashed potatoes and the French onion soup was good. The atmosphere was nice, but we will not be returning as the price was not worth it.
K Riaz
This place is over hyped, for starters I ordered the Jumbo onion rings thinking g they are gourmet and must be really good. The onion rings tasted like they were either frozen or plain flour batter, need less to say there is nothing jumbo about them and taste is very mid. The Sour dough bread is amazing but without the salty butter. Service was very good. I had the lobster bisque soup the taste is there but very water down. The consistency i would compare to a water based soup. I ordered the surf and turf, let's see if they make this any better than the onion rings. Final verdict the petiet filet is good the lobster not so much. Lobster was over done and too salty. Portions are very very small.
Ian Parrish
Wonderful atmosphere coupled with excellent service. Food was cooked to perfection, although I've had better steaks elsewhere. Mac and cheese, mashed potatoes, and the shrimp cocktail are all must-tries. My wife and I went for our anniversary and they went above and beyond to provide a special dinner for us. I've been back several times with groups since and it's always just as good.
David Townsend
Delicious offerings to be sure. We had the Salmon and the Toasted Chicken that was simply superb. Fully enjoyed a fantastic dinner. Kelly was our server and was extra ordinary.
