OC
Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom
Pizza and taps in a welcoming Wichita setting.
3.4
Pizza
$$
Pizza and taps in a welcoming Wichita setting.
Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom is a pizza restaurant and bar in Wichita (2240 N Tyler Rd STE 100), offering pizza, American fare, and a taproom experience. Reviews show a mix of praise for a wonderful atmosphere, delicious pepperoni rolls, and great service on some visits, alongside critiques of slow service, order mistakes, and pace issues on others. The venue emphasizes pizza and taps in a casual setting with varied guest experiences.
No photos available
Freshly made pizzas with a variety of toppings, from classic pepperoni to specialty combinations.
Extensive taproom offering local and regional craft beers, perfect for pairing with your meal.
Full-service restaurant with a lively atmosphere, ideal for family meals or casual outings.
Convenient meal takeaway options, including delivery through services like DoorDash for enjoy-at-home dining.
American-style appetizers, entrees, and bar snacks like Italian nachos, available in the taproom.
Claim Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom to update business info, respond to reviews, and access analytics.
Overall rating
Lucas Duncan
Whoever made the pepperoni rolls on December 17 2025 at noonish for a doordash order needs a raise and needs to teach everyone else how to make them. Delicious. Thank you so much 🙌🫶
JC
Food: Italian nachos, which our family calls "pasta nachos", were more like antipasto nachos. The cheese wasn't melted, the pepperoni's were cold, and with nothing to hold it together all the toppings fell to the bottom. We had to dig the toppings out with our fingers since we never got any silverware. Service: Drinks were left empty. I politely mentioned to the server he was doing okay, but that we never got any silverware. He said "SIlverware is definately essential" and then never brought our silverware. I got up and asked the bartender for some so we could put our leftovers in a to-go box. Atmosphere: Bar is too close to the dining tables. Belligerent drunk up at the bar. Not one sentence without at least 2 slurs for an hour.
Eeep Jeep
Do yourself a favor and just order door dash. Worst service I have had at a resturant in 10 years. Pizza is pretty dang good though. might have just been the lunch staff, but it was pitiful. Long waits. wrong orders. server would bring 1 thing at a time in 1 hand. Get server trays. multi task. call the guy from bar rescue. I paid 60 bucks for trash.
Dan Welden
Food was good but nothing to write home about. Portions could be bigger. Service was great though.
Ronnie Shepherd
Wonderful atmosphere wasn’t busy at all the food and service was exceptional. Definitely enjoyed my meal with my brother just snacking on a quiet afternoon lunch.
