Poppy Bakery

Peter Sciortino Bakery, a beloved Milwaukee neighborhood bakery on Brady Street, offers high-quality Italian baked goods at fair prices. Customers praise divine tiramisu, fresh cookies, and cannolis with creative toppings, plus friendly, attentive service. Shima's warm welcome and thoughtful recommendations highlight the inviting, neighborhood vibe.

Located in the Milwaukee Public Market at 400 N Water St, C. Adam's Bakery offers a tempting lineup of fresh cookies, cupcakes, macarons, and custom cakes. Customers praise the display, the freshness, and the flavorful treats, as well as friendly, attentive service and thoughtful touches like napkins and utensils. The shop earns consistently positive reviews for quality and variety.

Rocket Baby Bakery in Wauwatosa offers a Parisian-inspired bakery and cafe experience with breads, pastries, soups, sandwiches, and coffee. The almond croissant is a customer favorite and often sells out, with online ordering and reservations encouraged. Inside is cozy with a rustic vibe, and a large outdoor pavilion adds seating. The staff are praised for friendliness, and the shop is pet-friendly, though some reviews note occasional online ordering hiccups.

Simma's Bakery in Wauwatosa welcomes guests with a warm atmosphere and a wide array of party treats and desserts. Revered for wedding cakes, cheesecakes, and the Raspberry Mousse cake, it delivers delicious flavors and elegant presentation. Reviewers praise friendly, top-tier service and find prices very reasonable for Milwaukee-area desserts, with the shop located at 817 N 68th St, Wauwatosa, WI 53213.

Grebe's Bakery, located at 5132 W Lincoln Ave in West Allis, WI, is a beloved bakery and deli known for donuts, pastries, and quick counter service. Reviews highlight wedding donuts as a hit (175 assorted donuts with seamless pickup) and praise friendly staff, fast lines, and nostalgic aromas. The shop offers hot ham and rolls, coffee, and to-go treats. One review notes a ham-special quality issue, but overall customers treasure the memory-filled experience.

Blue's Egg + Bakery in Milwaukee welcomes guests with bright breakfasts, brunches, and bakery favorites in a clean, roomy space. Guests praise fast, friendly service and accommodating hosts, with outdoor seating available. The menu features fresh ingredients, customizable options, daily specials, and a bakery lineup from monkey bread to silk pie. Reservations are recommended.