RS
Rare Steakhouse
Rare Steakhouse: Bold steaks, fine wines, and unforgettable Madison nights.
5
Steakhouses
$$$$
Rare Steakhouse: Bold steaks, fine wines, and unforgettable Madison nights.
Rare Steakhouse in Madison charms with dry- and wet-aged steaks, an extensive wine list, and a menu of cocktails. Guests enjoy outdoor patio dining with a view of the Capitol, while insiders note a posh yet vibrant atmosphere. The staff consistently delivers attentive, top-tier service and thoughtful wine pairings, making it a popular spot for special occasions and four-course meals.
No photos available
Wet-aged and dry-aged steaks including New York strip and filet mignon, cooked to perfection.
Fresh seafood like sautéed scallops paired with seasonal vegetables such as asparagus and green beans.
Extensive wine list and specialty cocktails, including smoked old fashioneds, expertly paired with meals.
Intimate dining experiences for anniversaries and celebrations with customized service.
Outdoor seating with views of the Wisconsin State Capitol for al fresco meals.
Claim Rare Steakhouse to update business info, respond to reviews, and access analytics.
Overall rating
Patrick McHugh
Amazing experience. We had reservations for a Saturday night at 6. We each ordered drinks i had a stella and she had specialty mixer which she said was fantastic. We did not get an appetizer though they all looked good. I had a new york strip and she got filet mignon with sautéed scallops along with asparagus and green beans. I'm not great with wine or really care for it but our server paired such a fantastic wine to go with our meal. It was delicous!!! It was loud inside but we could still talk and hear each other. There were kids there but all well behaved. I wish I hadn't tossed the receipt so I could give a shout out to our server, best service I've ever had, and best steak. We'll be back!!
Megan Sneed
Had one of the best dining experiences in a very long time! Our server, Kristen, was absolutely amazing. She was one of the sweetest servers we have ever had. She recommended some delicious cocktails, including the smoked old fashioned, which was AMAZING. Our steaks were cooked to perfection, and our glasses were never empty with Kristen’s strong attention to detail. The best way to end out 2025 with great food and service!
Jesus Sanz
Made a reservation for our aniversary. Staff great us grat; really friendy. Had a reservation, we got seated, but we wanted a different table, they were kind to let us choose a different table. Service was amazing, food...no words to explain how good the food was, amazing...from the Starters, to the main dish, all good. Recommend 100%
Kyle Meise
We had a fantastic 4 course dinner with 2 perfectly paired J Henry bourbon neats, and 2 specialy curated cocktails. Was a great atmosphere, staff was extremely accommodating, and the chef prepared a wonderful meal to pull it all together. The food was very well balanced, delectable, and displayed in a simple elegance. Not often do I spend 4 hours at a restaurant and walk away wishing it lasted longer. Highly recommend anyones special event to be hosted here if you want an intimate and perfectly executed evening.
Tracy Cooper
A classic steakhouse with amazing meat selections, wet aged and dry aged steaks. We sat outside on the patio area with a view of the capital building while we dined. Susie was a super sweet waitress who made our anniversary special. They have an extensive wine list and cocktail menu. Very posh. Very loud inside. Bathrooms are ok. No parking close by unless you are lucky enough to find street parking.
