Services Offered
New York-Style Pizza
Large, thin-crust pizzas with authentic flavor, available by the slice or whole pie, including specialties like Meat Lovers and Tricolore.
Lunch Combos
Affordable midday meals featuring a cheese slice, garlic knots, and a drink for a quick and satisfying option.
Pasta & Appetizers
Hearty pasta dishes, mozzarella sticks, and other Italian favorites, perfect for sharing or as a main course.
Dine-In & Takeout
Casual indoor and outdoor seating for groups of all sizes, plus convenient takeout for enjoying our food at home.
Catering & Large Parties
Ideal for family gatherings or events, with accommodating service and menu options to feed a crowd.
Reviews
4.6(5 reviews)
Rating Distribution
5
3
4
2
3
0
2
0
1
0
D
Daxton Johnson
via Google
about 2 months ago
Very very good NY pizza! Was especially a fan of the Drunken Uncle pizza, and the waiter service (like from Holly!) was responsive and kind! Good for larger family groups, and absolutely delicious pasta and bread!
J
Julievia Google
2 months ago
Phenomenal pizza... you'll keep ordering even though you're feeling full. Brought dessert home and enjoyed that too. We will definitely be back with friends who come into town craving pizza.
J
Joshua Dvia Google
3 months ago
Casual, fun, friendly and great food. This is the pizza I've been looking for! Some say they have New York style pizza, but they really don't. Sal's Gilbert Pizza really does though! Large, thin, very savory with a true New York style, feel, taste and texture. I loved it! Pretty good bartender too, and nice.
M
Moncerrath Navavia Google
4 months ago
I came in during lunch on a Tuesday and they offer a great lunch menu. You order at the counter, pay and they provide you with your number. You are able to sit in any of the two sides of the restaurant. They offer outdoor seating but it appears it's for larger parties. The tables are long. I order the lunch combo: 1 cheese slice, 6 garlic knots and drink for $10.88 after tax. The staff brought my pizza slice and informed me my garlic knots would be out soon since they were making a fresh batch. The marinara sauce was missing some salt but they had table salt so that was an easy fix. My food was hot, I enjoyed the food and felt the combo was a good portion.
T
Taj Wvia Google
6 months ago
Sal’s Gilbert Pizza really hit the spot! The mozzarella sticks were breaded to perfection and paired perfectly with the marinara. For pizza, I tried the Pepperoni, Baked Ziti, Tricolore, White Pizza, and Meat Lovers — each one was delicious in its own way. The Tricolore was so unique I had to try it, and the Meat Lovers was a must for me. The slices are generous in size, making it hard to choose a favorite. The restaurant itself has a clean, inviting, family-friendly atmosphere with lots of natural light, which I really appreciated. Overall, this is a solid spot for great New York–style pizza in Gilbert, and I’ll definitely be back to explore more of the menu.
