Artisanal breads including seeded rolls and dinner rolls, baked daily for optimal freshness and flavor.
A wide selection of flaky pastries and addictive cookies, perfect for desserts or gifts, with seasonal specialties.
Outstanding handcrafted Sicilian pizza, known for its delicious taste whether enjoyed hot or cold.
Premium deli meats and fresh breads for custom sandwiches, ideal for quick lunches or takeaway meals.
Custom orders for events and holidays, including Christmas cookies and party platters, with efficient service.
This bakery is an absolute gem! The cookies were amazing—perfectly baked with great flavor in every bite. The pastries were incredibly fluffy and flaky, clearly made with care and high-quality ingredients. My absolute favorite, though, was the Sicilian pizza. It was outstanding and just as delicious hot as it was cold, which says a lot about how well it’s made. Everything I tried was fresh, comforting, and memorable. The staff here are also so friendly, they'll even give you little samples to try. I can't stop myself from spending $30-$50 every time I walk in, the food is just so good! I can’t wait to come back and try more—highly recommend stopping here!
This place is such a hidden gem. If you are looking for a great Italian deli, then look no further. I have ordered for pickup multiple times and have been very impressed with everything. Their seeded rolls and small dinner rolls are the best. The space itself is fairly small, with only a few seats if you want to eat in. Even when it is busy, the staff gets people in and out quickly. I can't wait to come back and try more of what they offer!
A hidden gem. The bakery has delicious and amazing treats. The place has a small deli. Weekly items available. Friendy and wonderful customer service. Plenty of parking.
This bakery/deli is such a hidden gem to have locally in Milwaukee. Not only do they have the most delicious Italian cookie selection but they also have freshly made bread & deli meat as well. Their customer service goes above and beyond. I am in no way a desert person but their pastries are superb. I definitely recommend making a stop here if you are in the area- you will NOT regret it 🤗
I stopped in for some Christmas cookies and bread; the place was packed since it was Christmas Eve, but the staff was all hands on deck and moved fast for me. The cookies were excellent and highly addictive. As for which ones were best, I suggest you try them all for yourself

Milwaukee's hidden gem for authentic Italian baked goods, pastries, and deli delights.
No photos available
Scordato Bakery Inc is a beloved family-owned Italian bakery and deli in Milwaukee, celebrated for its exceptional quality and warm hospitality. We specialize in freshly baked breads, flaky pastries, addictive cookies, and outstanding Sicilian pizza, all made with care and premium ingredients. Our small deli offers premium meats and rolls, perfect for sandwiches. With friendly staff who often provide samples and a cozy atmosphere, we've earned a 4.8-star rating from hundreds of satisfied customers. Whether you're grabbing a quick treat or stocking up for a special occasion, we deliver comfort and flavor in every bite.
Claim Scordato Bakery Inc to update business info, respond to reviews, and access analytics.