SF
Sutton's Family Italian Restaurant
Sutton's Family Italian Restaurant: Warm, family-style Italian flavors with memorable service.
4.4
Italian
$$
Sutton's Family Italian Restaurant: Warm, family-style Italian flavors with memorable service.
Located in Lexington, KY, Sutton's Family Italian Restaurant serves Italian classics, pizza, and a welcoming bar-and-grill atmosphere with catering and delivery options. Guests praise friendly, attentive service—especially Collin—and flavorful, made-from-scratch dishes like pasta, meatballs, and Manzo Parmesan Pasta. The hometown vibe, plus lunch deals, keeps guests coming back.
No photos available
Enjoy classic Italian dishes like pasta, pizza, and meatballs in a family-friendly restaurant setting.
Freshly made pizzas with a variety of toppings, available for dine-in, takeout, or delivery.
Professional catering for events and gatherings, featuring our signature Italian menu items.
Special discounted lunch offerings for a quick and affordable midday meal.
Convenient delivery service to bring our delicious Italian food straight to your door.
Indulge in homemade desserts like limoncello cake, tiramisu, and bread pudding.
Claim Sutton's Family Italian Restaurant to update business info, respond to reviews, and access analytics.
Overall rating
Darrell Swinford
Just a great hometown place! Friendly service. Great food. I don't know what more you could ask for. They make their dishes from scratch. Usually the owner is walking around. I don't find I've ever had a bad experience.
Diego Gonzalez
This place is amazing. I loved everything I’ve had over the past two days and will definitely keep coming back to try more of the menu. The service was outstanding. Colin was super funny, welcoming, and gave great recommendations. I came here one day, loved it so much, and had to come back the next day. On my first visit, I had the pasta alla vodka and the meatballs, and both were excellent. I highly recommend the meatballs. My girlfriend ordered the Manzo Parmesan Pasta, it was so creamy. On my second visit, I got the chicken parm and my girlfriend ordered the spaghetti. The chicken parm was fantastic, it had perfect adhesion, was so crispy, and so good. We also tried the pepperoni pups, which were amazing, crunchy, cheesy, and served with an incredible marinara sauce. For dessert, the limoncello cake was very lemony with the perfect texture. I also tried the bread pudding and tiramisu, and both were really good. My favorite items were the meatballs, Manzo Parmesan Pasta, and the limoncello dessert. Sorry for rambling, I just had a really amazing experience.
Olivia Caudill
Me and my boyfriend stumbled upon this restaurant and it is a gem! The service was wonderful. Collin, our server, had great conversation and was very welcoming, making the experience memorable. Every dish we had was delicious full of flavor. I had the manzo parmesan pasta, and it was amazing! If you're after great pasta and even better service, this is the place to be. Highly recommended! P. S. We are even coming back for lunch tomorrow seeing as they offer lunch deals.
Minoo Hosseinzadeh
First, as far as I know, this is the only place at Lex which serves fried mushrooms, which I love! It’s juicy and delicious! We also ordered tenders which were a bit over fried. The pizza was good though. They were late in bringing the starter bread. They originally forgot and we asked them to bring. Then, they brought after 3-5 minutes. Generally, I dint like the atmosphere. The tables are placed really closed next to each others and the lights are not good at all.
C Christian
Collin is the best!!! I’ve visited several times now, as he recommended by far one of my favorite Vegetarian dishes. He goes above and beyond across the board! My food, always right on the money. Best quality service and food, so much, I keep coming back! On my birthday, Collin really touched my heart. I love his Spirit! Thank you!!
