Authentic Italian cuisine with handmade pasta, fresh seafood, and irresistible desserts in Peoria.
The Sicilian Butcher offers a vibrant dining experience with a focus on traditional Italian flavors and modern twists. Located in Peoria, AZ, this restaurant features handmade pasta, fresh seafood dishes, and a renowned dessert selection including gelato, cannoli, and the signature Nutella lobster tail pastry. The welcoming atmosphere includes both indoor and outdoor seating, perfect for family dinners, celebrations, or casual outings. With attentive service and a diverse menu, it brings a taste of Sicily to Arizona.
No photos available
Fresh, handcrafted pasta entrees with a variety of sauces and flavors, including gnocchi and lasagna.
Creative meatball offerings like the Meatball Wheel, featuring pesto, truffle, and other unique varieties.
Decadent desserts including gelato, custom cannoli with choice of shell and filling, and Nutella lobster rolls.
A full bar serving Italian-inspired cocktails and beverages to complement your meal.
Catering to parties and celebrations with attentive service and special arrangements for birthdays and holidays.
Claim The Sicilian Butcher to update business info, respond to reviews, and access analytics.
Overall rating
Renee Blayden
This was a lobster roll with vanilla was AMAZING. The outside was shaped like a lobster tail but it was like a croissant . Hard and flakey on the outside was soft on the inside and then it had vanilla cream or you had a choice of Nutella. I’m really glad I do not live anywhere near this restaurant. Otherwise I’d be there every other day, getting one of these, they were so good. They had  gelato and an original cannoli among with so many other desserts! You got to pick your shell and filling for the cannoli. My MIL said their gelato tastes like it did when she traveled to Italy. All of the desserts looked AMAZING. We went there with my MIL for Christmas Eve dinner. My dish for dinner was ok but I should have got the lasagna as it was a smaller portion than what everyone else got.
mariah sosa
First Time and it was amazing. The food was great and a staff was amazing. Our server was Michael T and he was Excellent. My husband and I will definitely be back.
Liz T
We had party of 5 and not one person liked their food. I ordered the ménage a trois looked good but had literally no flavor at all only thing that was good was the cocktails and the Italian saganaki. service was good ambience of good but sorry not the food Edit: I spoke with the manager Jason, he reached out to apologize. We appreciated the apology and are willing to try the restaurant again.
Katrina
Perfecto, delicious, highly recommend. Meatball Wheel was unique and delectable; each meatball was yummy but the pesto and truffle were my favorites. Gnocchi Mac and cheese was good, Gnocchi was pillowy and super cheesy and I enjoyed the herb topping. Pasta entrees were great, great variety and flavors. Nutella lobster dessert really hit the spot, Nutella cream filling was light but great. Staff was friendly and attentive, space was large with indoor and outdoor seating. Buon Appetito, Piatto Pulito 😋
Jackie Crofts
Outstanding! Loved everything about this place. We had a great time celebrating birthdays, the staff were amazing, the food was amazing, the homemade pasta & cookies amazing! The manager Jason was very kind & made us feel special. We got a few free desserts- Thank you✨ I was craving the food all weekend so I went back with my hubby to try other dishes & we were not disappointed. They have a pretty big selection for dishes so I'll be back to try more for sure. I highly recommend this location✨