Worthington Jewelers

Diamonds Pearls & Jade, located at 4422 N High St in Columbus, offers custom engagement rings and one-of-a-kind pieces crafted with care. Customers praise knowledgeable, friendly service and a personal, non-corporate experience. With a focus on quality craftsmanship and clear communication, the shop creates durable, timeless jewelry that is proudly worn.

Jeff Johnson & Co in Columbus, OH (5025 Arlington Centre Blvd #130) delivers high-quality jewelry, repairs, upgrades, and estate pieces with a focus on custom design. Customers praise Carol for attentive, expert service and exquisite, unique creations that feel like art. The welcoming shop atmosphere and professional staff make every visit a trusted, memorable jewelry journey.

Diamonds Direct Columbus at 1330 Polaris Pkwy is a jewelry store known for engagement rings and repairs. Reviews highlight attentive, knowledgeable staff like Ryan Choops, Marci Gold, Lorenzo, Enrique Cervantes, and Kevin, who offer friendly, no-pressure guidance and quick, careful repairs. Customers praise exquisite ring selection and personalized service that helps them find the perfect pieces.

Krysty Designs in Columbus offers custom jewelry design, on-site modifications, and redesigns of existing pieces. Led by Brad Krysty and a friendly team, the store guides customers through a collaborative process with warm, attentive service and meticulous craftsmanship. Clients celebrate memory-filled creations, on-site stud adjustments, and store credit for old pieces, all culminating in one-of-a-kind jewelry that feels personal.

Diamond Cellar in Columbus is praised for professional, personalized jewelry shopping, from resizing rings to selecting engagement rings and notable watches such as Rolex. Reviewers at both Columbus locations describe a welcoming team—Dawn, Jeff, Jim, Mary—who guide customers with care, transparent processes, and helpful tools like 3D online models and wax replicas. The result is a first-class, memorable experience.

Evolved Body Art in Columbus, OH provides body art services and a jewelry selection at 2520 Summit St. Customers describe a welcoming, professional team and clear aftercare guidance, with standout experiences from piercings by Rayo and tattoos with Kez. While some reviews mention pricing concerns, the shop is noted for attentive service and a comfortable environment for piercings and tattoos.