P

Peter Lyonsvia Google

2 months ago

This was our first visit to 1889, and found this place based on the positive buzz online. It does not disappoint! They start you off with a solid menu of traditional, I guess I’d say understated pizzas that emphasize nuanced flavors and quality ingredients over bulk and large numbers of ingredients. The whole staff was super helpful and friendly. I even made a last-minute change to my order when Erica at the checkout told me her personal favorite combo; Quattro Frommagio with the addition of Italian sausage and a side of honey with chili oil. SO GOOD!! One of my sons commented it was the best pizza crust he’d ever eaten. And the atmosphere is cool, too. Nice dining room, not over-lit. Oh yeah, and a lot of nice wines and a half dozen or so excellent beers on tap. We’ll be back!

A

Amy DeCourseyvia Google

6 months ago

This was such a disappointing experience. Met my dinner companion at 6 and ordered. Salad was brought out at 6:15. My pizza never arrived until my friends got up and asked for it. Then 10+ minutes later they brought me something that’s not even on the menu. I’m so confused how they thought that was my order. Chicken, tomatoes, banana peppers and bbq sauce. When I took that back up, they urgently made my correct pizza which was The Prized Pig (received at 6:48pm) and it doesn’t look anything like the photo on the website. The bbq sauce on this is more like thousand island dressing. Pretty disappointing experience. If we return, I’ll stick to Margherita only. The staff was clueless, but very nice. Food took way too long for a very empty restaurant at a 6pm on a Saturday night. Apparently saturday night kids eat free so my son’s food was free which helped an otherwise salty experience.

F

Fr. Jay Kythe, OSBvia Google

7 months ago

The pizza was delicious! The crust was thin and crispy, not what I expected from what I thought would be a traditional neapolitan pizza. The ingredients were fresh. The atmosphere was modern but also very relaxed. You looked at a menu on the wall and then ordered at a counter. The sodas were refillable and self-service. It was all delicious and the staff were super friendly.

L

Luke Davidsonvia Google

7 months ago

We stopped in here as a secondary option due to another place having a ridiculous line around the building. I am glad that we went here instead. This was our first time visiting 1889 Pizza Napoletana and we will for sure be back. When we walked in we really liked the aesthetics of the restaurant. It was very clean and well kept. The staff greeted us right away and informed us where the menu was as it was our first time. There are numerous selections to choose from. I ordered The Butcher pizza and it was amazing. I definitely could’ve shared with my significant other and would have been content. The serving sizes are roughly a medium pizza so they could easily be split between 2 people. The atmosphere was inviting and they had a solid play list playing in the restaurant. Overall we were thoroughly impressed and plan to return next time we’re in Kansas City.

K

Keith Bentelvia Google

11 months ago

this location definitely had Fun atmosphere! Great pizza! Coke products for those that care. Beautiful outdoor seating. The inside was a mixture of comfortable and fun. Great location for families or friends. Just hanging out. Service was friendly and fast. I know I said it earlier but the pizza was really good. Plenty of options pre-design pizzas or build your own. Sadly, I don't need any photos of the pizza. It was too good and I ate it very quickly...