Big Apple Pizza

Lexy's Pizza in Fort Wayne serves Chicago-style-inspired pies with quality dough, sauce, and fresh toppings. Diners praise the sausage roll with tangy BBQ sauce and both deep-dish and thin-crust options. The carry-out-only, small building pairs with friendly service, and customers note generous toppings and a roughly one-hour wait when busy.

Johnny OX Pizzeria serves real, quality pizza in Fort Wayne at 1622 Broadway. Reviews praise fast service, a thin, slightly crisp crust with flavorful sauce and premium toppings, including vegan options. Many compare the pies to New Haven-style classics, while noting friendly staff, open communication, and a locally owned, family-run approach.

Clara’s Pizza King is a Fort Wayne pizza restaurant at 321 W State Blvd. Customers praise friendly, attentive service from staff like Hallee, Lindsey G, and Melinda, along with hot pies and plentiful toppings. The menu features half-baked breadsticks and a pepperoni/sausage pizza. Feedback ranges from outstanding hospitality to mixed opinions on crust and sauce.

Three Fires Pizza in Fort Wayne (5215 Illinois Rd Suite 101) serves a broad pizza menu with a crispy-on-the-outside, soft-inside crust. Reviewers praise flavorful appetizers and generous options, including gluten-free and cauliflower crusts to accommodate dietary needs, with attentive service for allergies. Experiences vary, with some guests noting cleanliness and consistency concerns.

Mama Mia's Pizza -St Joe in Fort Wayne delivers quality Italian-inspired pizza and dishes at a hometown price. Located at 6656-A St Joe Rd, it earns praise for fresh ingredients, fast, friendly service, and consistent flavor. Regulars call it one of the area's best local pizza spots, offering great value in a welcoming, family-friendly atmosphere.

Giordano's at 10180 Diebold Rd, Fort Wayne delivers Chicago-style deep-dish pizza for dine-in or takeout. Guests praise flavorful sauces, customizable toppings, and hot, on-time carryout, with friendly, helpful staff and a clean setting. A few experiences mention longer waits and occasional topping inconsistencies, but the overall impression remains inviting for pizza lovers.