Lexy's Pizza

Big Apple Pizza at 120 W Wayne St in Fort Wayne serves hot, flavorful pizzas praised as among Fort Wayne's best Neapolitan pies. Guests note quick, friendly service, generous portions for the price, and standout sides like garlic knots and cannoli cake. The restaurant also features clean restrooms and a welcoming, casual atmosphere.

Johnny OX Pizzeria serves real, quality pizza in Fort Wayne at 1622 Broadway. Reviews praise fast service, a thin, slightly crisp crust with flavorful sauce and premium toppings, including vegan options. Many compare the pies to New Haven-style classics, while noting friendly staff, open communication, and a locally owned, family-run approach.

Clara’s Pizza King is a Fort Wayne pizza restaurant at 321 W State Blvd. Customers praise friendly, attentive service from staff like Hallee, Lindsey G, and Melinda, along with hot pies and plentiful toppings. The menu features half-baked breadsticks and a pepperoni/sausage pizza. Feedback ranges from outstanding hospitality to mixed opinions on crust and sauce.

Three Fires Pizza in Fort Wayne (5215 Illinois Rd Suite 101) serves a broad pizza menu with a crispy-on-the-outside, soft-inside crust. Reviewers praise flavorful appetizers and generous options, including gluten-free and cauliflower crusts to accommodate dietary needs, with attentive service for allergies. Experiences vary, with some guests noting cleanliness and consistency concerns.

Mama Mia's Pizza -St Joe in Fort Wayne delivers quality Italian-inspired pizza and dishes at a hometown price. Located at 6656-A St Joe Rd, it earns praise for fresh ingredients, fast, friendly service, and consistent flavor. Regulars call it one of the area's best local pizza spots, offering great value in a welcoming, family-friendly atmosphere.

Giordano's at 10180 Diebold Rd, Fort Wayne delivers Chicago-style deep-dish pizza for dine-in or takeout. Guests praise flavorful sauces, customizable toppings, and hot, on-time carryout, with friendly, helpful staff and a clean setting. A few experiences mention longer waits and occasional topping inconsistencies, but the overall impression remains inviting for pizza lovers.